Policy Press
Fourteen The global politics of disablement: assuming impairment and erasing complexity
Abstract
This chapter is about the discourse of mental health as ‘global’, and its situation within a wider global discourse of illness and disability. It argues that the distress caused by societal conditions and/or trauma, the impairment caused by psychiatric ‘treatment’, and impairments caused by conditions of inequality and by persistent poverty are often erased in global disability discourse. When we consider distress and impairment in contexts of poverty, it becomes important to understand the socio-political complexity within which all illness and impairments are embedded. Highlighting the social complexity of impairment and considering the entanglements of poverty and disability, this chapter argues that to increase overall wellbeing a global redistribution of power and resources may be more effective than increasing access to psychiatry and drugs.
Abstract
This chapter is about the discourse of mental health as ‘global’, and its situation within a wider global discourse of illness and disability. It argues that the distress caused by societal conditions and/or trauma, the impairment caused by psychiatric ‘treatment’, and impairments caused by conditions of inequality and by persistent poverty are often erased in global disability discourse. When we consider distress and impairment in contexts of poverty, it becomes important to understand the socio-political complexity within which all illness and impairments are embedded. Highlighting the social complexity of impairment and considering the entanglements of poverty and disability, this chapter argues that to increase overall wellbeing a global redistribution of power and resources may be more effective than increasing access to psychiatry and drugs.
Kapitel in diesem Buch
- Front Matter i
- Contents iii
- About the authors v
- Foreword xiii
- Introduction 1
-
Disjunctures between disability and madness
- Unreasonable adjustments? Applying disability policy to madness and distress 13
- What we talk about when we talk about disability: making sense of debates in the European user/survivor movement 27
- Inconvenient complications: on the heterogeneities of madness and their relationship to disability 43
- Unsettling impairment: mental health and the social model of disability 57
-
Theorising distress and disablement
- Towards a socially situated model of mental distress 69
- The Capabilities Approach and the social model of mental health 83
- Psycho-emotional disablism in the lives of people experiencing mental distress 99
-
Applying social models of disability
- Psycho-emotional disablism, complex trauma and women’s mental distress 115
- Linking ‘race’, mental health and a social model of disability: what are the possibilities? 127
- Social models of disability and sexual distress 139
- The social model of disability and suicide prevention 153
-
Universalising disability policy
- Advancing the rights of users and survivors of psychiatry using the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 171
- UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities: out of the frying pan into the fire? Mental health service users and survivors aligning with the disability movement 183
- The global politics of disablement: assuming impairment and erasing complexity 199
- Disabilities, colonisation and globalisation: how the very possibility of a disability identity was compromised for the ‘insane’ in India 215
-
Meeting places
- Neurodiversity: bridging the gap between the disabled people’s movement and the mental health system survivors’ movement? 231
- Distress and disability: not you, not me, but us? 245
- ‘It’s complicated’: blending disability and mad studies in the corporatising university 261
- Solidarity across difference: organising for democratic alliances 271
- Beyond the horizon: the landscape of madness, distress and disability 287
- References 293
- Index 333
Kapitel in diesem Buch
- Front Matter i
- Contents iii
- About the authors v
- Foreword xiii
- Introduction 1
-
Disjunctures between disability and madness
- Unreasonable adjustments? Applying disability policy to madness and distress 13
- What we talk about when we talk about disability: making sense of debates in the European user/survivor movement 27
- Inconvenient complications: on the heterogeneities of madness and their relationship to disability 43
- Unsettling impairment: mental health and the social model of disability 57
-
Theorising distress and disablement
- Towards a socially situated model of mental distress 69
- The Capabilities Approach and the social model of mental health 83
- Psycho-emotional disablism in the lives of people experiencing mental distress 99
-
Applying social models of disability
- Psycho-emotional disablism, complex trauma and women’s mental distress 115
- Linking ‘race’, mental health and a social model of disability: what are the possibilities? 127
- Social models of disability and sexual distress 139
- The social model of disability and suicide prevention 153
-
Universalising disability policy
- Advancing the rights of users and survivors of psychiatry using the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 171
- UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities: out of the frying pan into the fire? Mental health service users and survivors aligning with the disability movement 183
- The global politics of disablement: assuming impairment and erasing complexity 199
- Disabilities, colonisation and globalisation: how the very possibility of a disability identity was compromised for the ‘insane’ in India 215
-
Meeting places
- Neurodiversity: bridging the gap between the disabled people’s movement and the mental health system survivors’ movement? 231
- Distress and disability: not you, not me, but us? 245
- ‘It’s complicated’: blending disability and mad studies in the corporatising university 261
- Solidarity across difference: organising for democratic alliances 271
- Beyond the horizon: the landscape of madness, distress and disability 287
- References 293
- Index 333