Cyclic Deformation, Holdtime Creep and Thermomechanical Fatigue of an ODS Superalloy
-
Rainer Joos
and Eduard Arzt
Abstract
Time-dependent inelastic deformation during high-temperature low-cycle fatigue has been studied by subjecting the ODS superalloy MA 6000 to discretized hysteresis loops with holdtimes at constant load. The inelastic deformation during the holdtime, recorded as a function of stress and temperature, was expressed by rate equations. This procedure gives insight into the material behaviour at various points of a stress-strain hysteresis. It is then applied to predict the stress-strain response under isothermal and thermomechanical fatigue loading. From the deformation analysis and a comparison between calculated and experimental results, conclusions concerning the internal stress evolution and deformation mechanisms acting during cyclic loading can be drawn.
Literature
1. Sehitoglu, H.: Advances in Fatigue Lifetime Predictive Techniques, ASTM STP 1122 (1992) 47.10.1520/STP24152SSearch in Google Scholar
2. Mu, Z.: Schädigungsmechanismen bei der Kriech-Ermüdung in der Legierung 800H und ihre Beeinflussung durch die VersuchsfÜhrung, Dissertation, Univ. Stuttgart (1990).Search in Google Scholar
3. Elzey, D. M.; Arzt, E.: Metall. Trans. A 22A (1991) 837.10.1007/BF02658993Search in Google Scholar
4. Rie, K. T.; Olfe, J.: in: K. T. Rie (ed.), Low Cycle Fatigue and Elasto-Plastic Behaviour of Materials 3, Elsevier Applied Science, Berlin (1992) 222.10.1007/978-94-011-2860-5_37Search in Google Scholar
5. Manson, S. S.; Halford, G. R.; Hirschherg, M. H.: Symp. on Design for Elevated Temperature Environment, ASME (1971) 12.Search in Google Scholar
6. Halford, G. R.; Saltsman, J. F.; Verilli, M. J.; Arya, V.: Advances in Fatigue Lifetime Predictive Techniques, ASTM STP 1122 (1992) 107.10.1520/STP24155SSearch in Google Scholar
7. Halford, G. R.; Manson, S. S.: Thermal Fatigue of Materials and Components, ASTM STP 612 (1976) 239.10.1520/STP27895SSearch in Google Scholar
8. Spera, D. A.: A Linear Creep Damage Theory for Thermal Fatigue of Materials, Ph. D. Thesis, University of Wisconsin (1968).Search in Google Scholar
9. Buchmayr, B.; Hoffelner, W.: in: Brunetaud et al. (eds.), High Temperature Alloys for Gas Turbines 1982, D. Reidel Publ. Comp., Liege (1982) 547.Search in Google Scholar
10. Benn, R. C.; Mirchandani, P. K.: in: E. Arzt, L. Schultz (eds), New Materials by Mechanical Alloying Techniques, DGM-Informationsgesellschaft, Frankfurt (1988) 19.Search in Google Scholar
11. Singer, R. F.; Arzt, E.: in: W. Betz et al. (eds), High Temperature Alloys for Gas Turbines and Other Applications, D. Reidel Publ. Comp., Liège (1986) 97.Search in Google Scholar
12. Whittenherger, J. D.: Metall. Trans. A 15A (1984) 1753.10.1007/BF02666358Search in Google Scholar
13. Joos, R.: Thermomechanische Ermüdung von ODS-Superlegierungen, Dissertation, Univ. Stuttgart (1994).Search in Google Scholar
14. Arzt, E.; Timmins, R.: in: J. B. Marriot (ed.), Creep Properties of ODS Superalloys, A Summary of the Results Obtained by the ODS Group in COST 501, JRC Petten, The Netherlands (1991).Search in Google Scholar
15. Matejczyk, D. E.; Zhuang, Y.; Tien, J. K.: Metall. Trans. A 14A(1983) 241.10.1007/BF02651621Search in Google Scholar
16. Elzey, D. M.: Mechanismen der Ermüdung und Kriech-Ermüdung in dispersionsgehärteten Superlegierungen, Dissertation, Univ. Stuttgart (1989).Search in Google Scholar
17. Andrade, E. N. D. C.: Proc. Royal Soc. A84 (1910) 11.Search in Google Scholar
18. Argon, A. S.; Bhattacharya, A. K.: Acta metall. 35(1986) 1499.10.1016/0001-6160(87)90095-2Search in Google Scholar
19. Timmins, R.: Unpublished Results, MPI für Metallforschung, Stuttgart (1990).Search in Google Scholar
20. Arzt, E.: Res mechanica 31 (1991) 339.Search in Google Scholar
21. Rösler, H. J.; Arzt, E.: Acta metall. mater. 38 (1990) 671.10.1016/0956-7151(90)90223-4Search in Google Scholar
22. Takeuchi, S.; Argon, A. S.: J. Mater. Sci. 11 (1976) 1542.10.1007/BF00540888Search in Google Scholar
23. Frost, H. J.; Ashby, M. F.: Deformation Mechanism-Maps, Pergamoon Press, Oxford (1982).Search in Google Scholar
Appendix A Fit Functions for Holdtime Creep Data
Region I: This region with negative deformation rates characterizes the unloading situation when the specimen is still under high absolute stresses and stress and strain rate have the same sign (Fig. 4). In Fig. A1 the data of region I are plotted on a logarithmic scale. They can be fitted by a power-law equation of the form:

The holdtime creep data for negative stresses can be fitted by a power-law function (Eq. (A1)).
where ɛ̇I is the mean deformation rate, nI the stress exponent (nI = 8), AI a fitparameter (AI = 1.4 · 10–34 m2). E is the temperature-dependent Young’s modulus given in [16]:
and D is the volume diffusivity; data for its activation energy Q and pre-exponential factor D0 were taken for Ni20Cr from [23]; D0 = 1.6 · 10–4 m2/s, Q = 285 kJ/mol.
The upper bound of region I data is given by the x-axis in Fig. 4 (ɛ̇ = 0). The stresses at the intersection of the curves with the x-axis do not cause any permanent inelastic deformation which means that the effective stress is zero and the internal stress equals the applied stress. In Fig. A2 the internal stresses are plotted as a function of temperature on a logarithmic scale. This temperature dependence can be described by the following expression (σi in MPa and T in K):

Temperature dependence of the internal stresses σi determined from holdtime creep tests. The data can be described by an exponential function of temperature (Eq. (A3)).
Region II: The strain rates in region II are positive (Fig. 4). Only a weak stress dependence exists, and all datapoints except the 1050 °C values approach a straight line which separates region II from region III. For positive stresses the strain rate can here be expressed as a linear function of stress:
For negative stresses the fit functions correspond to straight lines between the intersection of the y-axis (σ = 0 and ɛ̇ = 6.8 · 10–6 s–1) and the points on the x-axis which characterize the appropriate internal stress (σ = σί(T), ɛ̇ = 0).
Region IV: The data for positive stresses and strains are plotted in normalized form in Fig. A3. Two regions of different stress dependence exist as can be seen most clearly in the 1050 °C and 750 °C data. For high stresses the stress exponent is nIV = 3.5 for all temperatures. Assuming that nIV is not temperature dependent, a power-law fit function was selected which is illustrated in Fig. A3 as parallel lines:
The normalization of the creep rate and the stresses by the diffusivity D and by the temperature dependent Young’s modulus (E(T)), respectively, shows that the temperature dependence of the creep behaviour in this region is not determined by volume diffusion alone (Fig. A3). For an accurate description of the region IV data AIV(T) is an empirical function of temperature (T in K):
Region III: The data in the transition between regions II and IV cannot be satisfactorily described by Eqs (A4) and (A5). Therefore the following empirical equation has been applied to describe the behaviour in region III:
The pre-exponent AIII and the stess exponent nIII are functions of temperature and were determined as:
where T has to be expressed in K.
The fit functions of regions III and IV are illustrated in Fig. A4 for the 800 °C and 950 °C data. The full lines represent the mean values of the three fit equations which were applied in order to smoothen the curves.

Fit procedure for an accurate description of the holdtime creep data. The final fit functions are a mean value of the fit equations for regions III and IV. The result is illustrated for the 800 °C and the 950 °C data.
Appendix B Numerical Calculation of Stress-strain Hysteresis Loops
In the algorithm of the applied programme, the desired cycle with a given time-dependence of strain and temperature and a given strain amplitude was divided into j = 100 points of constant δɛ = (2 · Δɛ)/j, Δt = t/j and δT = (2 · ΔT)/j. Starting with σ1 = 0, ɛ1 = 0 and T1 = (Tmax–Tmin)/2, time, strain and temperature were increased in a stepwise manner and the stresses σj were calculated iteratively in the following way:
The stop-criterion of the iteration procedure was chosen as a deviation better than 0.01 % between the desired strain and the strain recalculated from the appropriate stress σj. The functions for the stress and temperature dependences of the strain rates are given in Eqs. (A1) and (A3) to (A9) and the temperature dependence of the Young’s modulus follows Eq. (A2).
© 1998 Carl Hanser Verlag, München
Articles in the same Issue
- Frontmatter
- Editorial
- Zur Werkstoffwoche ’98
- Aufsätze
- Cyclic Deformation, Holdtime Creep and Thermomechanical Fatigue of an ODS Superalloy
- Lattice Parameters of γ and γ' Phases in Superalloy SC16 in Unconstrained Condition
- Ostwald Ripening of the Matrix Phase Surrounding Dispersoids
- Properties of Vacancies in Copper Determined by Electrical Resistivity Techniques
- Reactions of Hydrogen and Oxygen with Copper Melts Measured with a Modified CHAPEL Technique
- Thermodynamic Calculation of Diffusion Paths Applied to the Oxidation of γ-TiAl
- Isothermal Sections of Phase Equilibria in the Al–AlCo–AlNi System
- Experimental Study and Thermodynamic Assessment of Phase Equilibria in the Mn-Sc System
- Thermodynamics of Liquid Al–Cu–Zr Alloys
- Interdiffusion Paths in the Diffusion Couple Ti–SiC
- Modellierung der einachsigen Zug- und Druck-Verformung kugelgestrahlter Zylinderproben aus vergütetem 42 CrMo 4 und der dabei auftretenden Makroeigenspannungsänderungen
- Mitteilungen der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Materialkunde e.V.
- Personen
- Hochschulnachricht
- Buchbesprechung
- Trends
- Veranstaltungen
Articles in the same Issue
- Frontmatter
- Editorial
- Zur Werkstoffwoche ’98
- Aufsätze
- Cyclic Deformation, Holdtime Creep and Thermomechanical Fatigue of an ODS Superalloy
- Lattice Parameters of γ and γ' Phases in Superalloy SC16 in Unconstrained Condition
- Ostwald Ripening of the Matrix Phase Surrounding Dispersoids
- Properties of Vacancies in Copper Determined by Electrical Resistivity Techniques
- Reactions of Hydrogen and Oxygen with Copper Melts Measured with a Modified CHAPEL Technique
- Thermodynamic Calculation of Diffusion Paths Applied to the Oxidation of γ-TiAl
- Isothermal Sections of Phase Equilibria in the Al–AlCo–AlNi System
- Experimental Study and Thermodynamic Assessment of Phase Equilibria in the Mn-Sc System
- Thermodynamics of Liquid Al–Cu–Zr Alloys
- Interdiffusion Paths in the Diffusion Couple Ti–SiC
- Modellierung der einachsigen Zug- und Druck-Verformung kugelgestrahlter Zylinderproben aus vergütetem 42 CrMo 4 und der dabei auftretenden Makroeigenspannungsänderungen
- Mitteilungen der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Materialkunde e.V.
- Personen
- Hochschulnachricht
- Buchbesprechung
- Trends
- Veranstaltungen
