How Do Private CAM Therapies Affect Integrative Health Care Settings in a Publicly Funded Health Care System?
-
Daniel Hollenberg
“Integrative health care” (IHC), combining various aspects of Western biomedicine and complementary/alternative medicine (CAM), is a relatively new development in health care systems. IHC is recognized internationally, yet the occurrence of private CAM therapies and their various effects on IHC settings has not extensively been analyzed. This paper presents findings from a larger study of three IHC settings in Canada conducted between 2002 and 2003. The main research question addressed here is: How have private CAM therapies affected IHC settings combining CAM and biomedicine in a publicly funded health care system? Drawing on ethnography, 38 in-depth interviews are drawn upon, including those with 15 biomedical and eight CAM practitioners, 13 patients and two health care managers. Ethnographic observation and document analysis was conducted at each site. Findings illustrated that patients could not consistently afford unfunded CAM treatments, resulting in the premature termination of an integrative care plan. CAM practitioners from the private sector could not uniformly attend group rounds, resulting in disrupted care co-ordination. Certain biomedical institutions viewed CAM as a commodity from which to generate revenue and lower budgetary deficits. This study argues that the unfunded nature of CAM therapies in public health systems, although CAM has therapeutic value, does not contribute to an equitable partnership when attempting to integrate biomedicine and CAM. Future analyses of IHC need to take into account the complexities of health system context that continues to shape IHC.
©2011 Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin/Boston
Articles in the same Issue
- Review Article
- Pharmacology of Huperzine A, an Alkaloid Isolated from Huperzine Serrata, a Novel Cognition Enhancer with Dual Cholinergic and NMDA Action. Implications in Schizophrenia and Dementia
- Research Article
- Fuzzy Rule Based Systems in Classification of Terminalia Chebula Fruits of Complementary and Alternative Medicine
- A Natural, Multi-Mechanistic Supplement Approach for Improving Cardiovascular Risk Factors
- How Do Private CAM Therapies Affect Integrative Health Care Settings in a Publicly Funded Health Care System?
- Preventive Effects of an Extract of Erythrina Lysistemon (Fabaceae) on Some Menopausal Problems: Studies on the Rat
- Bridge Building and Integrative Treatment of People with Multiple Sclerosis. Research-based Evaluation of a Team-building Process
- The Effects of Honey Compared With Sucrose and a Sugar-free Diet on Neutrophil Phagocytosis and Lymphocyte Numbers after Long-term Feeding in Rats
- Effect of Andrographolide on Monkey Hepatocytes against Galactosamine Induced Cell Toxicity : An In-Vitro Study
- Ginger Modulates Lymphocyte Activity in Vitro and in Vivo and Modestly Prolongs Cardiac Allograft Survival
- Discussion Paper
- Orthodox Use, or Misuse, of Complementary & Alternative Medicine
- Using the Behavioral Model for Complementary and Alternative Medicine: The CAM Healthcare Model
- Conference Presentation
- Coming of Age -- Emerging Issues and New Directions in CAM Research: Abstracts from the Fourth Annual IN-CAM Symposium November 1 & 2, 2007, Vancouver, Canada
Articles in the same Issue
- Review Article
- Pharmacology of Huperzine A, an Alkaloid Isolated from Huperzine Serrata, a Novel Cognition Enhancer with Dual Cholinergic and NMDA Action. Implications in Schizophrenia and Dementia
- Research Article
- Fuzzy Rule Based Systems in Classification of Terminalia Chebula Fruits of Complementary and Alternative Medicine
- A Natural, Multi-Mechanistic Supplement Approach for Improving Cardiovascular Risk Factors
- How Do Private CAM Therapies Affect Integrative Health Care Settings in a Publicly Funded Health Care System?
- Preventive Effects of an Extract of Erythrina Lysistemon (Fabaceae) on Some Menopausal Problems: Studies on the Rat
- Bridge Building and Integrative Treatment of People with Multiple Sclerosis. Research-based Evaluation of a Team-building Process
- The Effects of Honey Compared With Sucrose and a Sugar-free Diet on Neutrophil Phagocytosis and Lymphocyte Numbers after Long-term Feeding in Rats
- Effect of Andrographolide on Monkey Hepatocytes against Galactosamine Induced Cell Toxicity : An In-Vitro Study
- Ginger Modulates Lymphocyte Activity in Vitro and in Vivo and Modestly Prolongs Cardiac Allograft Survival
- Discussion Paper
- Orthodox Use, or Misuse, of Complementary & Alternative Medicine
- Using the Behavioral Model for Complementary and Alternative Medicine: The CAM Healthcare Model
- Conference Presentation
- Coming of Age -- Emerging Issues and New Directions in CAM Research: Abstracts from the Fourth Annual IN-CAM Symposium November 1 & 2, 2007, Vancouver, Canada
