Some Remarks on Fox and Pesetsky: ‘‘Cyclic Linearization of Syntactic Structure’’
-
Molly Diesing
Abstract
Fox and Pesetsky (F&P) make the claim that certain constraints on Object Shift and Quantifier Movement in Scandinavian can be explained within their model of the mapping between syntax and phonology. Among the salient features of this model are: Spell-out occurs phase-by-phase (as in recent work by Chomsky 2000, 2001a,b), and linearization relations established at each Spell-out point must be preserved (F&P’s property of Order Preservation). As F&P demonstrate quite elegantly, this system enforces successive cyclicity in wh-movement, in that non-successive-cyclic derivations will result in an ordering contradiction (violating Order Preservation). Thus, the ‘‘cyclicity’’ of successive cyclicity is shifted to being a by-product of the cyclic spelling-out process. One might still ask why Spell-out itself is cyclic, but this is certainly a welcome simplification.
© Walter de Gruyter
Articles in the same Issue
- Cyclic Linearization of Syntactic Structure
- Sound Patterns of Syntax: Object Shift
- Holmberg’s Generalization and Cyclic Linearization. Remarks on Fox and Pesetsky
- Re: CycLin and the role of PF in Object Shift
- Some Remarks on Fox and Pesetsky: ‘‘Cyclic Linearization of Syntactic Structure’’
- Comments on Erteschik-Shir’s article
- Linearization in two ways
- Remarks on cyclic linearization and order preservation
- Some notes on cyclic linearization
- Comments on Object Shift and Cyclic Linearization
- Object Shift and linearization at the PF interface
- How Phonological is Object Shift?
- A Note on ‘‘Cyclic Linearization’’
- Cyclic Linearization and its interaction with other aspects of grammar: a reply
- What is Syntax?
Articles in the same Issue
- Cyclic Linearization of Syntactic Structure
- Sound Patterns of Syntax: Object Shift
- Holmberg’s Generalization and Cyclic Linearization. Remarks on Fox and Pesetsky
- Re: CycLin and the role of PF in Object Shift
- Some Remarks on Fox and Pesetsky: ‘‘Cyclic Linearization of Syntactic Structure’’
- Comments on Erteschik-Shir’s article
- Linearization in two ways
- Remarks on cyclic linearization and order preservation
- Some notes on cyclic linearization
- Comments on Object Shift and Cyclic Linearization
- Object Shift and linearization at the PF interface
- How Phonological is Object Shift?
- A Note on ‘‘Cyclic Linearization’’
- Cyclic Linearization and its interaction with other aspects of grammar: a reply
- What is Syntax?