Home Hannibal’s March and Roman Imperial Space in Livy, Ab urbe condita, Book 21
Article
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

Hannibal’s March and Roman Imperial Space in Livy, Ab urbe condita, Book 21

  • Virginia Fabrizi EMAIL logo
Published/Copyright: June 8, 2015
Become an author with De Gruyter Brill

Abstract

Livy’s account of Hannibal’s march from Spain to Italy in 218 BCE (Liv. 21,21–38) contains well-known geographical inconsistencies. However, the representation of space makes sense in narrative terms, which was, after all, what especially mattered to an audience that did not normally use maps as support for the reading of history. This paper attempts to investigate, first of all, how narrative structure and space interact, and to ask which are the main spatial landmarks which shape the account of the events. Secondly, it examines the symbolic representation of the space crossed by Carthaginians as universal space, through the repeated allusion to Hercules’ travels. Moreover, it studies how landscape description, and the re-use of literary topoi about places, contribute to single out the Alps as an especially significant, and symbolic, landmark. Finally, it shows how concepts about space can be renegotiated through speeches delivered by characters inside the text, and how this is connected to a meditation on the relationships between space and empire.

Acknowledgements

This paper is the final result of work that has gone through several stages. Some preliminary ideas were discussed during a work-in-progress workshop held by the University of Pavia in 2011 (“Cantieri d’Autunno”). A research scholarship for a stay at the Fondation Hardt (Geneva) in 2012 allowed me to carry out some further enquiries. I have written the present paper during my DRS COFUND Post-Doc Fellowship, co-financed by the Freie Universität Berlin and the Marie Curie Action COFUND (project reference number PCOFUND-GA-2010–267228). I wish to thank my supervisor, Prof. Ernst Baltrusch, for reading this paper and helping me to improve it. The presentation of some partial results during a Colloquium at the Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität in Munich, in spring 2013, allowed me to receive precious insights and feedback: I am grateful to Prof. Therese Fuhrer for that opportunity.

Bibliography

E. Adler, Valorizing the Barbarians. Enemy Speeches in Roman Historiography, Austin 2011.10.7560/726284Search in Google Scholar

–, “Speeches of Enemies and Criticism of Empire in Early Imperial Historiography”, in: D. Hoyos (ed.), A Companion to Roman Imperialism, Leiden 2012, 291–304.Search in Google Scholar

M. von Albrecht, Silius Italicus. Freiheit und Gebundenheit römischer Epik, Amsterdam 1964.Search in Google Scholar

J.-M. André, “La politique alpine de Claude et de Néron”, in: M. Vacchina (ed.), La Valle d’Aosta e l’arco alpino nella politica del mondo antico (Atti del Convegno Internazionale di Studi St. Vincent, 25/26 Aprile 1987), Aosta 1988, 129–140.Search in Google Scholar

I. D’Arco, “Il sogno premonitore di Annibale e il pericolo delle Alpi”, QS 55, 2002, 145–162.Search in Google Scholar

R. G. Austin (ed.), Aeneidos liber primus, Oxford 1971.Search in Google Scholar

G. Barruol, Les peuples préromains du sud-est de la Gaule. Étude de géographie historique, Paris 1969.Search in Google Scholar

G. de Beer, Hannibal’s March, London 1967.Search in Google Scholar

D. van Berchem, Les routes et l’histoire. Études sur les Helvètes et leurs voisins dans l’empire romain, Genève 1982.Search in Google Scholar

C. Bonnet, Melqart. Cultes et mythes de l’Héraclès tyrien en Méditerranée, Leuven 1988.Search in Google Scholar

L. Braccesi, “La tradizione augustea delle Alpi ‘Claustra Italiae’ e la sua proiezione ideologica”, in: M. Vacchina (ed.), Problemi di politica augustea (Atti del Convegno di Studi di St. Vincent, 25/26 Maggio 1985), Aosta 1986, 36–49.Search in Google Scholar

J. Briscoe (ed.), Titi Livi Ab urbe condita libri XXXI-XL. II: libri XXXVI-XL, Stuttgart 1991.10.1515/9783110959529Search in Google Scholar

J. Briscoe, “Livy’s Sources and Methods of Composition in Books 31–33”, in: J. D. Chaplin/C. S. Kraus (eds.), Livy (Oxford Readings in Classical Studies), Oxford 2009, 461–475 (reprint of J. Briscoe, A Commentary on Livy; Books XXXI-XXXII, Oxford 1973, 1–12).Search in Google Scholar

K. Brodersen, Terra Cognita. Studien zur römischen Raumerfassung (Spudasmata 59), Hildesheim 1995.Search in Google Scholar

Th. Buettner-Wobst (ed.), Polybii Historiae. Vol. I, libri I-III, Stuttgart 31964 (= 21905).Search in Google Scholar

E. Burck, Einführung in die dritte Dekade des Livius, Heidelberg 21962.Search in Google Scholar

–, Die Erzählungskunst des T. Livius, Berlin/Zürich 21964.Search in Google Scholar

–, “The Third Decade”, in: T. A. Dorey (ed.), Livy (Greek and Latin Studies. Classical Literature and its Influence), London 1971, 21–46.Search in Google Scholar

–, Das Geschichtswerk des Titus Livius, Heidelberg 1992.Search in Google Scholar

P. J. Burton, “The Last Republican Historian. A New Date for the Composition of Livy’s First Pentad”, Historia 49, 2000, 429–446.Search in Google Scholar

G. Cipriani, L’epifania di Annibale, Bari 1984.Search in Google Scholar

K. Clarke, “An Island Nation: Re-Reading Tacitus’ Agricola”, JRS 91, 2001, 94–112.10.1017/S0075435800015872Search in Google Scholar

N. J. De Witt, “Rome and the ‘Road of Hercules’”, TAPhA 72, 1941, 59–69.10.2307/283041Search in Google Scholar

R. Dion, “La voie héracléenne et l’itinéraire transalpin d’Hannibal”, in: M. Renard (ed.), Hommages à Albert Grenier (Collection Latomus 58), Bruxelles 1962, 527–543.Search in Google Scholar

–, “Explication d’un passage des Res Gestae Divi Augusti”, in: J. Heurgon/G. Picard/W. Seston (eds.), Mélanges d’archéologie, d’épigraphie et d’histoire offerts à Jérome Carcopino, Paris 1966, 249–270.Search in Google Scholar

E. Doblhofer, “Livius und andere ‘Imperialisten’”, in: E. Lefèvre/E. Olshausen (eds.), Livius. Werk und Rezeption. Festschrift für Erich Burck zum 80. Geburtstag, München 1983, 133–162.Search in Google Scholar

T. A. Dorey (ed.), Titi Livi Ab urbe condita libri XXI-XXII, Leipzig 1971.Search in Google Scholar

V. Fabrizi, Mores veteresque novosque. Rappresentazioni del passato e del presente di Roma negli Annales di Ennio, Pisa 2012.Search in Google Scholar

D. C. Feeney, “The Reconciliations of Juno”, CQ 34, 1984, 179–194.10.1017/S0009838800029426Search in Google Scholar

A. Feldherr, Spectacle and Society in Livy’s History, Berkeley/Los Angeles 1998.10.1525/9780520919693Search in Google Scholar

J. de Foucault (ed.), Polybe, Histoires, Livre III, Paris 1971.Search in Google Scholar

E. Gabba, “Significato storico della conquista Augustea delle Alpi”, in: M. Vacchina (ed.), La Valle d’Aosta e l’arco alpino nella politica del mondo antico (Atti del Convegno Internazionale di Studi St. Vincent, 25/26 Aprile 1987), Aosta 1988, 53–61.Search in Google Scholar

H. A. Gärtner, Beobachtungen zu Bauelementen in der antiken Historiographie, besonders bei Livius und Caesar, Wiesbaden 1975.Search in Google Scholar

M. R. Girod, “La géographie de Tite-Live”, ANRW II 30.2, 1982, 1190–1229.10.1515/9783110839685-007Search in Google Scholar

M. Le Glay, “Vocontii”, KlP 5, München 1975.Search in Google Scholar

U. Händl-Sagawe, Der Beginn des 2. Punischen Krieges. Ein historisch-kritischer Kommentar zu Livius Buch 21, München 1995.Search in Google Scholar

N. Horsfall, “Illusion and Reality in Latin Topographical Writing”, G&R 21, 1985, 197–208.10.1017/S0017383500030515Search in Google Scholar

D. Hoyos, “Crossing the Durance with Hannibal and Livy: The Route to the Pass”, Klio 88, 2006, 408–465.10.1524/klio.2006.88.2.408Search in Google Scholar

W. Huss, “Hannibal und die Religion”, in: C. Bonnet/E. Lipińsky/P. Marchetti (eds.), Religio Phoenicia. Acta Colloquii Namurcensis habiti diebus 14 et 15 mensis Decembris anni 1984 (Studia Phoenicia 4), Namur 1986, 223–238.Search in Google Scholar

P. Jal (ed., transl.), Tite-Live, Histoire Romaine. Tome XI, livre XXI, Paris 1988.Search in Google Scholar

P. Janni, La mappa e il periplo. Cartografia antica e spazio odologico, Roma 1984.Search in Google Scholar

R. C. Knapp, “La ‘uia Heraclea’ en el occidente: mito, arqueología, propaganda, historia”, Emerita 54, 1986, 103–122.10.3989/emerita.1986.v54.i1.664Search in Google Scholar

C. S. Kraus, “Livy”, in: C. S. Kraus/A. J. Woodman, Latin Historians (Greece & Rome. New Surveys in the Classics 27), Oxford 1997, 51–81.10.1017/S0533245100030248Search in Google Scholar

J. F. Lazenby, Hannibal’s War. A Military History of the Second Punic War, Warminster 1978.Search in Google Scholar

D. S. Levene, Livy on the Hannibalic War, Oxford 2010.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198152958.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

T. J. Luce, “The Dating of Livy’s First Decade”, TAPhA 96, 1965, 209–240.10.2307/283727Search in Google Scholar

–, Livy. The Composition of His History, Princeton 1977.Search in Google Scholar

E. Malaspina, “Tipologie dell’inameno nella letteratura latina. Locus Horridus, paesaggio eroico, paesaggio dionisiaco: una proposta di risistemazione”, Aufidus 23, 1994, 7–22.Search in Google Scholar

S. McPhee, Hannibal’s Alpine Journey and the Wasteland of Italy in Livy Book XXI and XXII, online at https://www.academia.edu/3034837/Hannibals_Alpine_Journey_and_the_Wasteland_of_Italy_in_Livy_Books_21_and_22, 2013.Search in Google Scholar

A. Mehl, “Imperium sine fine dedi – die augusteische Vorstellung von der Grenzlosigkeit des Römischen Reiches”, in: E. Olshausen/H. Sonnabend (eds.), Stuttgarter Kolloquium zur historischen Geographie des Altertums 4, 1990, Amsterdam 1994, 431–464.Search in Google Scholar

E. Mensching, “Zur Entstehung und Beurteilung von Ab urbe condita”, Latomus 45, 1986, 572–589.Search in Google Scholar

E. Meyer, “Hannibals Alpenübergang”, MH 15, 1958, 227–241.10.1093/ajhp/15.3.241Search in Google Scholar

W. O. Moeller, “Once More the One-Eyed Man against Rome”, Historia 24, 1975, 402–410.Search in Google Scholar

C. Nicolet, L’inventaire du monde. Géographie et politique aux origines de l’Empire romain, Paris 1988.Search in Google Scholar

R. G. M. Nisbet/N. Rudd, A Commentary on Horace. Odes Book III, Oxford 2004.Search in Google Scholar

S. P. Oakley, “Livy and His Sources”, in: J. D. Chaplin/C. S. Kraus (eds.), Livy (Oxford Readings in Classical Studies), Oxford 2009, 439–460.Search in Google Scholar

W. R. Paton (ed., transl.), Polybius, The Histories. Vol. II (The Loeb Classical Library), London/Cambridge, MA, 1954.Search in Google Scholar

D. Pausch, Livius und der Leser. Narrative Strukturen in ab urbe condita, München 2011.10.4000/books.chbeck.1396Search in Google Scholar

G. Petrone, “Locus amoenus/locus horridus: due modi di pensare il Bosco”, Aufidus 5, 1988, 3–18.Search in Google Scholar

G. Ch. Picard, “La religion d’Hannibal”, RHR 163, 1963, 123–124.Search in Google Scholar

D. Proctor, Hannibal’s March in History, Oxford 1971.Search in Google Scholar

R. Rutherford, “Voices of Resistance”, in: C. S. Kraus/J. Marincola/C. Pelling (eds.), Ancient Historiography and its Contexts: Studies in Honour of A. J. Woodman, Oxford 2010, 312–330.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199558681.003.0019Search in Google Scholar

E. T. Sage (ed., transl.), Livy. X: Books XXXV–XXXVII (The Loeb Classical Library), London/Cambridge, MA 1958.Search in Google Scholar

E. de Saint-Denis, “Encore l’itinéraire transalpin d’Hannibal”, REL 51, 1973, 122–149.Search in Google Scholar

O. J. Schrier, “Hannibal, the Rhône and the ‘Island’: Some Philological and Metrological Notes”, Mnemosyne 59, 2006, 501–524.10.1163/156852506778881030Search in Google Scholar

J. Seibert, Forschungen zu Hannibal, Darmstadt 1993.Search in Google Scholar

A. Silberman (ed.), Pomponius Mela. Chorographie, Paris 1988.Search in Google Scholar

J. J. L. Smolenaars, “The Literary Tradition of the locus horridus in Seneca’s Thyestes”, in: J. Styka (ed.), Studies of Greek and Roman Literature (Classica Cracoviensia), Krakow 1996, 89–108.Search in Google Scholar

R. Syme, “Livy and Augustus”, HSCP 64, 1959, 27–87 (reprinted in: R. Syme, “Roman Papers”, ed. by E. Badian, Oxford 1979, 400–454).10.2307/310937Search in Google Scholar

M. Tarpin, “Frontières naturelles et frontières culturelles dans les Alpes du Nord”, in: G. Fabre (ed.), La montagne dans l’Antiquité. Actes du colloque de la Société des Professeurs d’Histoire Anciennes de l’Université, Pau mai 1990 (Cahiers de l’Université de Pau 23), Pau 1992, 97–120.Search in Google Scholar

H. Tränkle, Livius und Polybios, Stuttgart 1977.Search in Google Scholar

G. Tsitsiou-Chelidoni, “History Beyond Literature: Interpreting the ‘Internally Focalized’ Narrative in Livy’s Ab urbe condita”, in: J. Grethlein/A. Rengakos (eds.), Narratology and Interpretation: the Content of Narrative Form in Ancient Literature, Berlin/New York 2009, 527–554.10.1515/9783110214536.5.527Search in Google Scholar

A. Vasaly, “The Structure of Livy’s First Pentad and the Augustan Poetry Book”, in: D. S. Levene/D. P. Nelis (eds.), Clio and the Poets: Augustan Poetry and the Traditions of Ancient Historiography, Leiden/Boston 2002, 275–290.10.1163/9789047400493_015Search in Google Scholar

F. W. Walbank, “Some Reflections on Hannibal’s Pass”, JRS 46, 1956, 37–45.10.2307/297963Search in Google Scholar

–, A Historical Commentary on Polybius. Volume I: Commentary on Books I–VI, Oxford 1957.Search in Google Scholar

P. G. Walsh, Livy. His Historical Aims and Methods, Cambridge 1963.Search in Google Scholar

– (ed.), T. Livi Ab urbe condita liber XXI, London 1973.Search in Google Scholar

D. West (ed., transl., comm.), Horace, Odes III. Text, Translation and Commentary, Oxford 2002.Search in Google Scholar

K. Witte, “Über die Form der Darstellung in Livius’ Geschichtswerk”, RhM 65, 1910, 270–305; 359–419.Search in Google Scholar

J. C. Yardley (transl.)/D. Hoyos (intr., comm.), Livy, Hannibal’s War. Books Twenty-One to Thirty, Oxford 2006.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2015-6-8
Published in Print: 2015-6-1

© 2015 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Downloaded on 25.10.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/phil-2015-0007/html
Scroll to top button