Abstract
Two different scientific analyses-one destructive and one non-destructive-were conducted on two separate groups of bronze ornaments dating from 1500-1100 BC to investigate, amongst other traits, the metal composition of their copper-tin alloys. One group of artefacts was sampled, and polished thin sections were analysed using a scanning electron microscope (SEM). Results from the corrosion crust of copper-tin alloys, and the change measured within the elemental composition from the bulk metal to the surface, greatly influenced the interpretation of the second data set, which was measured using a handheld X-ray fluorescence (XRF) device. The surface of corroded bronze ornaments consists mostly of copper carbonates, oxides, and chlorides. Chemical processes, such as decuprification, change the element composition in such a manner that the original alloy cannot be traced with a non-destructive method. This paper compares the results of both investigations in order to define the possibilities and limits of non-destructive XRF analyses of corroded bronze artefacts.
References
Anker, D. (1982). Die Rontgenfluoreszenzanalyse in der Archaologie. In K. d. R.-G. Zentralmuseums (Ed.), Festschrift Hans-Jurgen Hundt. Teil 3: Fruhes Mittelalter (pp. 212-228). Mainz: Romisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseum Mainz.Search in Google Scholar
Bernard, M. C., & Joiret, S. (2009). Understanding corrosion of ancient metals for the conservation of cultural heritage. Electrochimica Acta, 54, 5199-5205.10.1016/j.electacta.2009.01.036Search in Google Scholar
Chase, W. (1994). Chinese bronzes: casting, finishing, patination and corrosion. In D. Scott, J. Podnay & B. Considine (Eds.), Ancient and Historic Metals (pp. 85-118). Cincinnati, Ohio: The Getty Conservation Institution.Search in Google Scholar
Constantinides, I., Adrianes, A., & Adams, F. (2002). Surface characterization of artificial corrosion layers on copper alloy10.1016/S0169-4332(02)00005-3Search in Google Scholar
reference materials. Applied Surface Science, 189, 90-101.Search in Google Scholar
Copper Development Association, I. (2008). Working with Copper. How to Apply Statuary and Patina Finsihes. https://www.copper.org/publications/pub_list/: Copper Alliance.Search in Google Scholar
Fernandes, R., van Os, B. J., & Huisman, H. D. (2013). The use of Hand-Held XRF for investigating the composition and corrosion of Roman copper-alloyed artefacts. Heritage Science, 1:30, 1-7.10.1186/2050-7445-1-30Search in Google Scholar
Groves, J. (2001, July of 2002 ). 16th Century Amber Varnish & Venetian Amber Varnish - Amber Varnishes available during the 1500-1600’s Retrieved 22-09, 2016.Search in Google Scholar
Harding, A. F. (2000). European Societies in the Bronze Age. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511605901Search in Google Scholar
Helfert, M., & Bohme, D. (2010). Herkunftsbestimmung von Romischer Keramik mittels portabler energiedispersiver Rontgenfluoreszenzanalyse (P-ED-RFA) - erste Ergebnisse einer anwendungsbezogenen Teststudie. In B. Ramminger & O. Stilborg (Eds.), Naturwissenschaftliche Analysen vor- und fruhgeschichtlicher Keramik I. Methoden, Anwndungsbereiche, Auswertungsmoglichkeiten (Vol. 176, pp. 11-30). Bonn: Dr. Rodolf Habelt GmbH.Search in Google Scholar
Härke, H. (1978). Probleme der optischen Emissionsspektralanalyse: Technische Moglichkeiten und methodische Fragestellungen. Prahistorische Zeitschrift, 53, 165-276.Search in Google Scholar
Junghans, S., Sangmeister, E., & Schroder, M. (1974). Kupfer und Bronze in der fruhen Metallzeit Europas. Berlin: Mann.Search in Google Scholar
Laux, F. (1971). Die Bronzezeit in der Luneburger Heide. Hildesheim: August Lax Verlag.Search in Google Scholar
Lutz, J., & Pernicka, E. (1996). Energy Dispersive X-Ray Fluorescence analysis of ancient Copper Alloys: Empirical Values for Precision and Accuracy. Archaeometry, 38, 2, 313-323.10.1111/j.1475-4754.1996.tb00779.xSearch in Google Scholar
Mircea, O., Sandu, I., Vasilache, V., & Sandu, I. G. (2012). A study on the Deterioration and Degradation of Metallic Archaeological Artifacts. International Journal of Conservation Science, 3(3), 179-188.Search in Google Scholar
Nørgaard, H. W. (2011). Die Halskragen der Bronzezeit im nordlichen Mitteleuropa und Sudskandinavien (Vol. 200). Bonn: Dr. Rudolf Habelt.Search in Google Scholar
Nørgaard, H. W. (2014a). Craftsmanship and Metalwork in the Nordic Bronze Age: craft organisation, craftspeople and their areas of contact. (PhD), Aarhus University, unpublished PhD-thesis.Search in Google Scholar
Nørgaard, H. W. (2014b). Valued Craftsmen: As important as prestige goods? -Some ideas about itinerant craftsmanship in the Nordic Bronze Age. In S. Reiter, H. W. Norgaard, Z. Kolzce & C. Rassmann (Eds.), Rooted in Movement. Aspects of Mobility in Bronze Age Europe (pp. 37-52). Aarhus: Jutland Archaeological Society.Search in Google Scholar
Nørgaard, H. W. (2015a). Genau hingesehen - Metallhandwerk in Mecklenburg zwischen 1550-1100 BC. Herstellungsspuren und Metallkompositionen als Indikator fur Metallwerkstatten in Mecklenburg. Bodendenkmalpflege in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Jahrbuch 61, 2013 (pp. 57-100). Schwerin: Abteilung Landesarchaologie im Landesamt fur Kultur und Denkmalpflege Mecklenburg-Vorpommern.Search in Google Scholar
Nørgaard, H. W. (2015b). Metalcraft within the Nordic Bronze Age: Combined metallographic and superficial imaging reveals the technical repertoire in crafting bronze ornaments. Journal for Archaeological Science, 64, 110-128.10.1016/j.jas.2015.10.005Search in Google Scholar
Nørgaard, H. W. (2015c). Tracing the Hand that Crafted: how individual working traces make Bronze Age ornaments talk. In P. Suchowska-Ducke, S. S. Reiter & H. Vandkilde (Eds.), Forging Identities. The Mobility of Culture in Bronze Age Europe. Report from a Marie Curie project 2009-2012 with concluding conference at Aarhus University, Moesgaard 2012. (pp. 101-110). Oxford: BAR International Series.Search in Google Scholar
Otto, H. (1973). Uber die Auswertung der Metallanalysen in Band 1 und 2 der “Studien zu den Anfangen der Metallurgie” (SAM). Acta Praehistoria et Archaeologica, 4, 1-9.Search in Google Scholar
Oudbashi, O., Emami, S. M., Ahmadi, H., & Davami, P. (2013). Micro-stratigraphical investigation on corrosion layers in ancient Bronze artefacts by scanning electron microscopy energy dispersive spectrometry and optical microscopy. Heritage Science, 1:21, 1-10.10.1186/2050-7445-1-21Search in Google Scholar
Pernicka, E. (1995). Gewinnung und Verbreitung der Metalle in prahistorischer Zeit. Jahrbuch des Romisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums Mainz, 37. Jahrgang(Teil 1), 21-129.Search in Google Scholar
Pernicka, E. (2010). Archaometallurgische Untersuchungen am und zum Hortfund von Nebra. In H. Meller & F. Bertemes (Eds.), Der Griff nach den Sternen. Intern. Symposium Halle (Saale) 16.-21. Februar 2005 (pp. 719-734). Halle: Landesmuseums fur Vorgeschichte.Search in Google Scholar
Pernicka, E. (2014). Provenance Determination of Archaeological Metal Objects. In B. W. Roberts & C. P. Thornton (Eds.), Archaeometallurgy in Global Perspective. Methods and Syntheses (pp. 239-268). London: Springer.Search in Google Scholar
Robbiola, L., Blengino, J.-M., & Fiaud, C. (1998). Morphology and Mechanisms of formation of Natural Patinas on Archaeological Cu-Sn Alloys. Corrosion Science, 40(12), 2083-2111.10.1016/S0010-938X(98)00096-1Search in Google Scholar
Sangmeister, E. (1971). Aufkommen der Arsenbronze in SO-Europa. In G. Novak (Ed.), Actes du VIIe Congres International des Sciences Prehistoriques et Protohistoriques, Beograd, 9-15 Septembre 1971 (pp. 109-129). Beograd.Search in Google Scholar
Šatović, D., Desnica, V., & Fazinić, S. (2013). Use of portable X-ray flourescence instrument for bulk alloy analysis on low corroded indoor bronzes. Spectrochimica Acta Part B, 89, 7-13.10.1016/j.sab.2013.08.007Search in Google Scholar
Stos-Gale, Z. A., & Gale, N. H. (2009). Metal provenancing using isotopes and the Oxford archaeological lead isotope database (OXALID). Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences, 1(3), 195-213.10.1007/s12520-009-0011-6Search in Google Scholar
Wadsak, M., Constantinides, I., Vittiglio, G., Adriaens, A., Janssens, K., Schreiner, M., Wuttmann, M. (2000). Multianalytical Study of Patina Formed on Archaeological Metal Objects from Bliesbruck-Reinheim. Mikrochimica Acta, 133, 159-164.10.1007/s006040070086Search in Google Scholar
Weisser, T. S. (1975). The de-alloying of copper alloys. In N. S. Brommelle, P. Smith, D. Leigh, A. Moncrieff, W. A. Oddy & P. Pratt (Eds.), Conservation in Archaeology and the Applied Arts. (pp. 207-214). London: The international Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works.Search in Google Scholar
Wolff, T. (2009). Referenzprobenfreie quantitative Mikri-Rontgenfluoreszenzanalyse. Berlin.Search in Google Scholar
Wolters, J. (1991). Der Gold- und Silberschmied. Werkstoffe und Materialien. Stuttgart.Search in Google Scholar
© 2017
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 License.
Articles in the same Issue
- Topical Issue: Advances in Arctic Archaeology
- Archaeological Site Vulnerability Modelling: The Influence of High Impact Storm Events on Models of Shoreline Erosion in the Western Canadian Arctic
- An Early Inupiaq Occupation: Observations on a Thule House From Cape Espenberg, Alaska
- Topical Issue: Uncovering Historical Routes for Sustainable Mobility: Methods, Tools and Case Studies
- The Various Ways of Being Mobile: Habitual Knowledge, Life-Strategies and the Ancient Route Networks on the Eastern Marmarica- Plateau (Northern Libyan Desert)
- Hide and Seek. Roads, Lookouts and Directional Visibility Cones in Central Anatolia
- All the Roads to Patavium: Morphology, Genesis and Development of the Roman Road Network Around Padua
- Perspectives for Network Analysis: Roman Roads, Barbarian Paths and Settlement Patterns in the Borderlands at the Limes Germanicus in the Main River Region
- The Road Network in the Longue Durée: A Reading Key of the History of Territories
- A Stratified Route Network in a Stratified Landscape. The Region of Enna (Central Sicily) from the Bronze Age to the 19 th c. AD.
- Sicilian Castles and Coastal Towers
- From Excavation to Restitution of the Networks of Roman and Pre-roman Roads: The Footprints of the 2222 m and 2535 m Leagues in the Carnute, Senon and Parisii Territories (Gallia Lugdunensis/France)
- Topical Issue on Portable XRF in Archaeology and Museum Studies, Edited by Davide Tanasi, Robert H. Tykot, Andrea Vianello
- Portable XRF on Prehistoric Bronze Artefacts: Limitations and Use for the Detection of Bronze Age Metal Workshops
- Portable XRF: A Tool for the Study of Corundum Gems
- Trace Elemental Characterization of Maltese Pottery from the Late Neolithic to Middle Bronze Age
- Provenance Study of Prehistoric Ceramics from Sicily: A Comparative Study between pXRF and XRF
- Investigation by pXRF of Caltagirone Pottery Samples Produced in Laboratory
- Monte Finocchito and Heloros Pottery Production: New Evidence through Technological Studies and Material Analysis
- PXRF Determination of the Obsidian Industry from the S–F Area of Piani della Corona EBA Settlement (Bagnara Calabra–RC, South Italy)
- Obsidian Studies in the Prehistoric Central Mediterranean: After 50 Years, What Have We Learned and What Still Needs to Be Done?
- Investigating Technological Changes in Copper-Based Metals Using Portable XRF Analysis. A Case Study in Sicily
- Regular articles
- Online Tribes and Digital Authority: What Can Social Theory Bring to Digital Archaeology?
- The Teotihuacan Anomaly: The Historical Trajectory of Urban Design in Ancient Central Mexico
- Reproducibility in the Field: Transparency, Version Control and Collaboration on the Project Panormos Survey
- Big-Men and Small Chiefs: The Creation of Bronze Age Societies
- Hunting High and Low: Gravettian Hunting Weapons from Southern Italy to the Russian Plain
- Erratum
- Erratum to: Monte Finocchito and Heloros Pottery Production: New Evidence through Technological Studies and Material Analysis
- Portable XRF on Prehistoric Bronze Artefacts: Limitations and Use for the Detection of Bronze Age Metal Workshops
Articles in the same Issue
- Topical Issue: Advances in Arctic Archaeology
- Archaeological Site Vulnerability Modelling: The Influence of High Impact Storm Events on Models of Shoreline Erosion in the Western Canadian Arctic
- An Early Inupiaq Occupation: Observations on a Thule House From Cape Espenberg, Alaska
- Topical Issue: Uncovering Historical Routes for Sustainable Mobility: Methods, Tools and Case Studies
- The Various Ways of Being Mobile: Habitual Knowledge, Life-Strategies and the Ancient Route Networks on the Eastern Marmarica- Plateau (Northern Libyan Desert)
- Hide and Seek. Roads, Lookouts and Directional Visibility Cones in Central Anatolia
- All the Roads to Patavium: Morphology, Genesis and Development of the Roman Road Network Around Padua
- Perspectives for Network Analysis: Roman Roads, Barbarian Paths and Settlement Patterns in the Borderlands at the Limes Germanicus in the Main River Region
- The Road Network in the Longue Durée: A Reading Key of the History of Territories
- A Stratified Route Network in a Stratified Landscape. The Region of Enna (Central Sicily) from the Bronze Age to the 19 th c. AD.
- Sicilian Castles and Coastal Towers
- From Excavation to Restitution of the Networks of Roman and Pre-roman Roads: The Footprints of the 2222 m and 2535 m Leagues in the Carnute, Senon and Parisii Territories (Gallia Lugdunensis/France)
- Topical Issue on Portable XRF in Archaeology and Museum Studies, Edited by Davide Tanasi, Robert H. Tykot, Andrea Vianello
- Portable XRF on Prehistoric Bronze Artefacts: Limitations and Use for the Detection of Bronze Age Metal Workshops
- Portable XRF: A Tool for the Study of Corundum Gems
- Trace Elemental Characterization of Maltese Pottery from the Late Neolithic to Middle Bronze Age
- Provenance Study of Prehistoric Ceramics from Sicily: A Comparative Study between pXRF and XRF
- Investigation by pXRF of Caltagirone Pottery Samples Produced in Laboratory
- Monte Finocchito and Heloros Pottery Production: New Evidence through Technological Studies and Material Analysis
- PXRF Determination of the Obsidian Industry from the S–F Area of Piani della Corona EBA Settlement (Bagnara Calabra–RC, South Italy)
- Obsidian Studies in the Prehistoric Central Mediterranean: After 50 Years, What Have We Learned and What Still Needs to Be Done?
- Investigating Technological Changes in Copper-Based Metals Using Portable XRF Analysis. A Case Study in Sicily
- Regular articles
- Online Tribes and Digital Authority: What Can Social Theory Bring to Digital Archaeology?
- The Teotihuacan Anomaly: The Historical Trajectory of Urban Design in Ancient Central Mexico
- Reproducibility in the Field: Transparency, Version Control and Collaboration on the Project Panormos Survey
- Big-Men and Small Chiefs: The Creation of Bronze Age Societies
- Hunting High and Low: Gravettian Hunting Weapons from Southern Italy to the Russian Plain
- Erratum
- Erratum to: Monte Finocchito and Heloros Pottery Production: New Evidence through Technological Studies and Material Analysis
- Portable XRF on Prehistoric Bronze Artefacts: Limitations and Use for the Detection of Bronze Age Metal Workshops