Home How Democratic Police Reforms Fail: A Law and Development Perspective on Institutional Processes of Change and Resistance
Article
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

How Democratic Police Reforms Fail: A Law and Development Perspective on Institutional Processes of Change and Resistance

  • Julia Maia Goldani EMAIL logo
Published/Copyright: March 18, 2024

Abstract

Democratic police reform (DPR) is a type of institutional reform that aims to make polices compatible with democratic political regimes. Though distinct approaches have been attempted in distinct contextual circumstances, promoting DPR has proven remarkably difficult. Successful cases are hard to find; across the globe, DPR efforts have had unsatisfactory outcomes, amounting to little or no sustainable change in dysfunctional police forces. What explains this systematic failure of DPR? Existing research has focused on determining the sociopolitical circumstances and/or reform methods that correlate with positive or negative DPR outcomes. However, there is a gap in the literature regarding how DPR fails – that is, the processes through which the above-mentioned variables interact with the police’s organizational environments, rules, and resistance mechanisms to produce unsatisfactory outcomes/failed reform. This paper proposes that an analytical framework based on law and development scholarship can help police reform scholars address these gaps. To develop this argument, I review and discuss existing theorizations on DPR failure, demonstrating the potential contributions of a law and development perspective. I suggest that a framework based on this perspective nuances existing approaches by emphasizing the contentious processes surrounding reform enactment and implementation. Unpacking these processes can represent a new research agenda for police reform scholarship.


Corresponding author: Julia Maia Goldani, Fundação Getulio Vargas Law School, São Paulo, Brazil, E-mail:

Award Identifier / Grant number: 2021/05078-4

Award Identifier / Grant number: 2023/02405-0

  1. Research funding: The São Paulo State Research Foundation (Fundação de Apoio à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo) supported the research conducted for this paper through grants n. 2021/05078-4 and n. 2023/02405-0.

References

Akbar, A. A., An abolitionist horizon for (Police) reform, 108 California Law Review, no. 6 (2020).10.2139/ssrn.3670952Search in Google Scholar

Akbar, A. A., Demands for a democratic political economy, 134 Harvard Law Review Forum (2020).Search in Google Scholar

Bachrach, P., & M. S. Baratz, Two Faces of Power, 56 American Political Science Review, no. 4 (1962).10.2307/1952796Search in Google Scholar

Bayley, D. H., The Police and Political Change in Comparative Perspective, 6 Law & Society Review, no. 1 (1971).10.2307/3052914Search in Google Scholar

Bayley, D. H., A foreign policy for democratic policing, 5 Policing and Society, no. 2 (1995).10.1080/10439463.1995.9964713Search in Google Scholar

Bayley, D. H., Changing the guard: Developing Democratic Police Abroad (Oxford University Press, 2006).10.1093/oso/9780195189759.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Bayley, D. H., Police reform: who done it? 18 Policing and Society, no. 1 (2008).10.1080/10439460701718518Search in Google Scholar

Berkowitz, D., K. Pistor & J. F. Richard, Economic development, legality, and the transplant effect, 47 European economic review, no. 1 (2003).10.1016/S0014-2921(01)00196-9Search in Google Scholar

Castro, H. A., Institutions are not Rules: Realigning the Ontology Behind Theories of Change, Political Studies OnlineFirst (2023).10.1177/00323217231179551Search in Google Scholar

Colletta, N. J., & R. Muggah, Context matters: interim stabilisation and second generation approaches to security promotion, 9 Conflict, Security & Development, no. 4 (2009).10.1080/14678800903345762Search in Google Scholar

Costa, A. T. M., Como as democracias controlam as polícias, Novos Estudos CEBRAP, no. 70 (2004).Search in Google Scholar

Davis, K. E., & M. J. Trebilcock, The relationship between law and development: Optimists versus skeptics, 56 American Journal of Comparative Law, no. 4 (2008).10.5131/ajcl.2007.0031Search in Google Scholar

Ellison, G., & N. W. Pino, Globalization, Police Reform and Development: doing it the western way? (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012).10.2139/ssrn.2262711Search in Google Scholar

Engel, R. S., H. D. McManus & G. T. Isaza, Moving beyond “Best Practice”: Experiences in Police Reform and a Call for Evidence to Reduce Officer-Involved Shootings, 687 Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, no. 1 (2020).10.1177/0002716219889328Search in Google Scholar

González, Y. M., Participation as a safety valve: Police reform through participatory security in Latin America, 61 Latin American Politics and Society, no. 2 (2019).10.1017/lap.2018.78Search in Google Scholar

González, Y. M., The Social Origins of Institutional Weakness: Preferences, Power, and Police Reform in Latin America, 71 World Politics, no. 1 (2019).10.1017/S004388711800014XSearch in Google Scholar

González, Y. M., Authoritarian Police in Democracy: contested security in Latin America (Cambridge University Press, 2020).10.1017/9781108907330Search in Google Scholar

Gordon, E., Security Sector Reform, Statebuilding and Local Ownership: Securing the State or its People? 8 Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding, no. 2–3 (2014).10.1080/17502977.2014.930219Search in Google Scholar

Greenwood, R., C. R. Hinings & D. Whetten, Rethinking institutions and organizations, 51 Journal of Management Studies, no. 7 (2014).10.1111/joms.12070Search in Google Scholar

Hodgson, G. M., What Are Institutions? 40 Journal of Economic Issues, no. 1 (2006).10.1080/00213624.2006.11506879Search in Google Scholar

Jensen, E. G., “The Rule of Law and Judicial Reform: the political economy of diverse institutional patters and reformers’ responses,” in E. G. Jensen & T. C. Heller (eds.), Beyond Common Knowledge Empirical Approaches to the Rule of Law (Stanford University Press, 2003).10.1515/9781503624160-014Search in Google Scholar

Light, M., Police reforms in the Republic of Georgia: The convergence of domestic and foreign policy in an anti-corruption drive, 24 Policing and Society, no. 3 (2014).10.1080/10439463.2013.784289Search in Google Scholar

Light, M., M. M. Prado & Y. Wang, Policing following political and social transitions: Russia, Brazil, and China compared, 19 Theoretical Criminology, no. 2 (2015).10.1177/1362480614568742Search in Google Scholar

Macaulay, F., “Cycles of police reform in Latin America,” in D. J. Francis (ed.), Policing in Africa (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012).10.1057/9781137010582_8Search in Google Scholar

Mahoney, J., & K. Thelen, Explaining Institutional Change: Ambiguity, Agency and Power (Cambridge University Press, 2010).10.1017/CBO9780511806414Search in Google Scholar

Malone, M. F. T., L. Dammert & O. J. Pérez, Making police reform matter in Latin America (Boulder: Lyenne Rienne Publishers, 2023).10.1515/9781685853013Search in Google Scholar

Marat, E, The politics of police reform: society against the State in Post-Soviet countries (Oxford University Press, 2018).10.1093/oso/9780190861490.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Marks, M., & D. Sklansky, “Introduction,” in M. Marks & D. Sklansky (eds.), Police Reform from the Bottom Up (London: Routledge, 2012).Search in Google Scholar

Milhaupt, C. J., & K. Pistor, Law & capitalism: What corporate crises reveal about legal systems and economic development around the world (University of Chicago Press, 2019).Search in Google Scholar

North, D. C., “The New Institutional Economics and Third World Development,” in et al.. (eds.), The New Institutional Economics and Third World Development (London: Routledge, 1997).Search in Google Scholar

O’Shea, L., Why democratic police reform mostly fails and sometimes succeeds: police reform and low state capacity, authoritarianism and neo-patrimonial politics (in the former Soviet Union), 33 Policing and Society, no. 3 (2023).10.1080/10439463.2022.2106983Search in Google Scholar

Prado, M. M., O paradoxo das reformas do estado de direito: quando reformas iniciais se tornam obstáculos para reformas futuras, 21 Revista de Sociologia e Política (2013).10.1590/S0104-44782013000100007Search in Google Scholar

Prado, M. M., & M. Trebilcock, Path dependence, development, and the dynamics of institutional reform, 59 University of Toronto Law Journal, no. 3 (2009).10.1353/tlj.0.0027Search in Google Scholar

Prado, M. M., & M. Trebilcock, Institutional bypasses: a strategy to promote reforms for development (Cambridge University Press, 2018).10.1017/9781108563116Search in Google Scholar

Prado, M. M., M. Trebilcock & P. Hartford, Police Reform in Violent Democracies in Latin America, 4 Hague Jorunal on the Rule of Law (2012).10.1017/S1876404512000164Search in Google Scholar

Robinson, L. O., Five Years after Ferguson: Reflecting on Police Reform and What’s Ahead, 687 Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, no. 1 (2020).10.1177/0002716219887372Search in Google Scholar

Shahnazarian, N., & M. Light, Parameters of police and non-reform in post-soviet regimes: the case of Armenia, 26 The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization, no. 1 (2018).Search in Google Scholar

Simonson, J., Police Reform Through a Power Lens, 130 The Yale Law Journal (2021).10.2139/ssrn.3731173Search in Google Scholar

Skogan, W. G., “Why reforms fail,” in M. Marks & D. Sklansky (eds.), Police Reform from the Bottom Up (London: Routledge, 2012).Search in Google Scholar

Von Jacobi, N., Institutional interconnections: Understanding symbiotic relationships, 14 Journal of Institutional Economics, no. 5 (2018).10.1017/S1744137417000558Search in Google Scholar

Walker, S., “The neglect of police unions: exploring one of the most important areas of American policing,” in M. Marks & D. Sklansky (eds.), Police Reform from the Bottom Up (London: Routledge, 2012).Search in Google Scholar

Willis, G. D., & M. M. Prado, Process and Pattern in Institutional Reforms: A Case Study of the Police Pacifying Units (UPPs) in Brazil, 64 World Development (2014).10.1016/j.worlddev.2014.06.006Search in Google Scholar

Received: 2024-01-10
Accepted: 2024-02-25
Published Online: 2024-03-18
Published in Print: 2025-02-25

© 2024 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Downloaded on 23.9.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/ldr-2024-0017/html?lang=en
Scroll to top button