Abstract
Many historians of early Judaism continue to generalize the various sources and finds related to the synagogues, as if we may continue to speak of a centralized synagogue institution with standardized traits. This tendency becomes apparent in the secondary literature surrounding Josephus’ two narratives regarding the Leontopolis temple from Bellum Judaicum (BJ) and Antiquitates Judaicae (AJ). Many scholars present both with exclusivist ideologies of the Jerusalem Temple, which leads them to treat the ἱερά in AJ 13.62–73 as standardized “synagogues” as we understand them. I will thus argue that Josephus uses this tradition in distinct, if not opposing, ways within his two histories. Whereas the BJ 7 passage is interested in the opposition to the Jerusalem Temple, the focal point of this entire book, the AJ 13 pericope is more concerned with the “ancestral customs” of the Jews and proper worship, as Onias contends with the many, heteropraxic Jewish ἱερά that existed in Egypt. Antiquitates is interested in showing the honours and rights bestowed upon the Jewish communities by foreign rulers, legitimizing their way of life. Despite some terminological correspondence, we must not theologize these ἱερά as proper synagogues, even if they were in the synagogue tradition. Instead, we should treat them as early institutions, which Josephus rejected due to syncretistic practices. This is in keeping with other Jewish ἱερά referred to as at least temple-like in Antiquitates. Moreover, such a reading is consistent with the external literary attestation and material character of Diaspora synagogues and worship practices, especially in Egypt. This reading of AJ 13.62–73 allows for us to treat the many Jewish assemblies in Egypt as a variegated group of holy places, which took on certain symbols and elements of Egyptian cultic practice, just as later synagogues would absorb elements of the surrounding cultures.
Bibliography
Barclay, John M. G. Jews in the Mediterranean Diaspora: from Alexander to Trajan. Berkeley: University of California, 1996.Search in Google Scholar
Bilde, Per. “Was hat Josephus über die Synagogue zu sagen?” In Internationales Josephus-Kolloquim Brussell 1998, edited by U. Jürgen, 15–35. Münster: Lit Verlag, 1999.Search in Google Scholar
Bilde, Per. Against Apion. Leiden: Brill, 2001Search in Google Scholar
Binder, Donald D. Into the Temple Courts: the place of the synagogue in the Second Temple Period. Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 1999.Search in Google Scholar
Bird, Michael. Crossing Over Sea and Land: Jewish proselytizing activity in the Second-Temple Period. Peabody: Hendrickson, 2009.Search in Google Scholar
Branham, Joan R. “Vicarious sacrality: temple space in ancient synagogues.” In Ancient Synagogues: historical analysis and archaeological discovery, edited by Dan Urman and Paul V. M. Flesher, 319–345. Leiden: Brill, 1995.Search in Google Scholar
Claußen, Carsten. Versammlung, Gemeinde, Synagoge: das hellenistisch-jüdische Umfeld der frühchristlichen Gemeinden. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht, 2002.Search in Google Scholar
Cohen, Shaye J. D. The Beginnings of Jewishness: boundaries, varieties, uncertainties. Berkeley: University of California, 1999.Search in Google Scholar
Collins, John J. Jewish Wisdom in the Hellenistic Age. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1997.Search in Google Scholar
Collins, John J. Between Athens and Jerusalem: Jewish identity in the Hellenistic diaspora. Second Edition. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000.Search in Google Scholar
Dion, Paul-Eugene. “Synagogues et Temples dans l’Égypte Hellénistique.” Science et Esprit 29 (1977): 45–75.Search in Google Scholar
Doran, Robert. “Jewish Hellenistic historians before Josephus.” ANRW II.20.1 (1986): 246–297.10.1515/9783110855715-008Search in Google Scholar
Engel, Helmut. “Was Weisheit ist und wie sie entstand, will ich verkünden.” In Lehrerin der Gerechtigkeit, edited by G. Hentschel and E. Zenger, 67–102. Leipzig: Benno, 1990.Search in Google Scholar
Feldman, Louis H. Jew and Gentile in the Ancient World. Princeton: Princeton U. P., 1993.10.1515/9781400820801Search in Google Scholar
Fine, Steven. This Holy Place: on the sanctity of the synagogue during the Greco-Roman period. South Bend: University of Notre Dame, 1997.Search in Google Scholar
Flesher, Paul V. M. “Prolegomenon to a theory of early synagogue development.” In Judaism in Late Antiquity III: where we stand: issues and debates in ancient Judaism, vol. 4.: the special problem of the ancient synagogue, edited by Alan J. Avery-Peck and Jacob Neusner, 27–39. Leiden: Brill, 2001.Search in Google Scholar
Frankfurter, David. “Egyptian religion and the problem of the category ‘sacrifice.’” In Ancient Mediterranean Sacrifice, edited by Jennifer Wright Knust and Zsuzsanna Varhelyi, 75–87. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 2011.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199738960.003.0003Search in Google Scholar
Frey, Jörg. “Temple and rival temple: the cases of Elephantine, Mt. Gerizim, and Leontopolis.” In Gemeinde ohne Tempel/Community without Temple, edited by Beate Ego, Armin Lange, and Peter Pilhofer, 171–203. Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr, 1999.Search in Google Scholar
Gilbert, Maurice. “La structure de la prière de Salomon.” Biblica 51 (1970): 301–331.Search in Google Scholar
Gilbert, Maurice. “The literary structure of the Book of Wisdom: a study of various views.” In The Book of Wisdom in Modern Research, edited by Angela Passaro and Giuseppe Bellia, 19–32. Berlin: de Gruyter, 2005.Search in Google Scholar
Gilders, William K. “Jewish sacrifice: its nature and function (according to Philo).” In Ancient Mediterranean Sacrifice, edited by Jennifer Wright Knust and Zsuzsanna Varhelyi, 94–103. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 2011.Search in Google Scholar
Goodenough, Edwin R. By Light, Light! The mystic gospel of Hellenistic Judaism. New Haven: Yale U. P., 1935.Search in Google Scholar
Goodman, Martin. Mission and Conversion: proselytizing in the religious history of the Roman period. Oxford: Clarendon, 1994.Search in Google Scholar
Griffiths, J. Gwyn. “Egypt and the rise of the synagogue.” In Ancient Synagogues: historical analysis and archaeological discovery. Volume 1, edited by Dan Urman and Paul V. M. Flesher, 3–16. Leiden: Brill, 1995.Search in Google Scholar
Gruen, Erich S. Culture and National Identity in Republican Rome. Ithaca: Cornell U. P., 1992.Search in Google Scholar
Gruen, Erich S. “The origins and objectives of Onias’ temple.” Scripta Classica Israelica 16 (1997): 67–70.Search in Google Scholar
Gruen, Erich S. Heritage and Hellenism: the reinvention of Jewish tradition. Berkeley: University of California, 1998.10.1525/9780520929197Search in Google Scholar
Gruen, Erich S. Diaspora: Jews amidst Greeks and Romans. Cambridge: Harvard U. P., 2002.10.4159/9780674037991Search in Google Scholar
Halpern Amaru, Betsy. “Land theology in Josephus’ Jewish Antiquities.” Jewish Quarterly Review 71.4 (1981): 201–229.10.2307/1454614Search in Google Scholar
Harland, Philip A. Associations, Synagogues, and Congregations. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2003.Search in Google Scholar
Hayward, Robert. “The Jewish temple at Leontopolis: a reconsideration.” Journal of Jewish Studies 33 (1982): 429–443.10.18647/1059/JJS-1982Search in Google Scholar
Hengel, Martin. “Proseuche und Synagoge: Jüdische Gemeinde, Gotteshaus und Gottesdienst in der Diaspora und in Palästina.” In The Synagogue: studies in origins, archaeology, and architecture, edited by Joseph Gutmann, 26–54. New York: Ktav, 1975.Search in Google Scholar
Hersey, George. The Lost Meaning of Classical Architecture. Cambridge: MIT, 1988.Search in Google Scholar
Holladay, Carl R. Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish authors: vol. 1: Historians. Chico: Scholars, 1983.Search in Google Scholar
Horbury, William and David Noy. Jewish Inscriptions of Graeco-Roman Egypt. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 1992.Search in Google Scholar
Hübner, Hans. Die Weisheit Salomos: Liber Sapietiae Salomonis übersetzt und erklärt. Göttingen: Vandenhoek and Ruprecht, 1999.Search in Google Scholar
Kasher, Aryeh. “Synagogues as ‘houses of prayer’ and ‘holy places’ in the Jewish communities of Hellenistic and Roman Egypt.” In Ancient Synagogues: historical analysis and archaeological discovery. Volume 1, edited by Dan Urman and Paul V. M. Flesher, 205–220. Leiden: Brill, 1995.Search in Google Scholar
Klauck, Hans-Josef. Herrenmahl und hellenistischer Kult: eine religionsgeschichtliche Untersuchung zum ersten Korintherbrief. Münster: Aschendorff, 1982.Search in Google Scholar
Krause, Andrew R. Rhetoric, Spatiality, and the First-Century Synagogue: the description and narrative use of Jewish institutions in the works of Flavius Josephus. Dissertation, McMaster University, 2015.Search in Google Scholar
Krauss, Samuel. Synogogale Altertümer. Berlin: Benjamin Harz, 1922.Search in Google Scholar
Lacquer, Richard. Der jüdische Historiker Flavius Josephus. Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1920.Search in Google Scholar
Landau, Tamar. Out-Heroding Herod: Josephus, rhetoric, and the Herod narratives. Leiden: Brill, 2006.10.1163/9789004331068Search in Google Scholar
Larcher, C. Études sur le Livre de la Sagesse. Paris: Gabalda, 1969.Search in Google Scholar
Leonhardt, Jutta. Jewish Worship in Philo of Alexandria. Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr, 2001.Search in Google Scholar
Levine, Lee I. Ancient Synagogue: the first thousand years. Second Edition. New Haven: Yale U. P., 2005.Search in Google Scholar
Levinskaya, Irina. “A Jewish or gentile prayer house? The meaning of προσευχή.” Tyndale Bulletin 41.1 (1990): 154–159.10.53751/001c.30512Search in Google Scholar
Lightstone, Jack N. Commerce of the Sacred: mediation of the divine among Jewish in the Greco-Roman world. Revised Edition. New York: Columbia U. P., 2006.Search in Google Scholar
Martin, M. J. School of Virtue and the Tent of Zion. Dissertation, University of Melbourne, 2000.Search in Google Scholar
Mason, Steve. Flavius Josephus on the Pharisees. Leiden: Brill, 1991.10.1163/9789004509108Search in Google Scholar
Mason, Steve. “Introduction to the Judean Antiquities.” In Judean Antiquities 1–4, edited by L. Feldman, xiii–xxxvi. Leiden: Brill, 2000.Search in Google Scholar
Mason, Steve. “The importance of the latter half of Josephus’ Judaean Antiquities for his Roman audience.” In Pentateuchal Traditions in the Late Second Temple Period, edited by Akio Moriya and Gohei Hata, 129–153. Leiden: Brill, 2012.10.1163/9789004223608_008Search in Google Scholar
McKnight, Scot. A Light among the Gentiles: Jewish missionary activity in the Second Temple Period. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1991.Search in Google Scholar
Mendelson, Alan. Philo’s Jewish Identity. Atlanta: Scholars, 1988.Search in Google Scholar
Niehoff, Marin. Philo on Jewish Identity and Culture. Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr, 2001.Search in Google Scholar
Noy, David. “A Jewish place of prayer in Roman Egypt.” Journal of Theological Studies 43.1 (1992): 118–122.10.1093/jts/43.1.118Search in Google Scholar
Peerbolte, Bert Jan Lietaert. “The hermeneutics of Exodus in the Book of Wisdom.” In The Interpretation of Exodus, edited by Riemer Roukema, 97–116. Leuven: Peeters, 2006.Search in Google Scholar
Rajak, Tessa. “Was there a Roman charter for the Jews.” Journal of Roman Studies 83 (1993): 107–123.10.2307/299011Search in Google Scholar
Rajak, Tessa. Josephus: the historian and his society. Second Edition. London: Duckworth, 2002.Search in Google Scholar
Rajak, Tessa. “The ancient synagogue: a review article.” Studia Philonica Annual 15 (2003): 100–108.Search in Google Scholar
Reece, James M. “Plan and structure in the Book of Wisdom.” Catholic Biblical Quarterly 27 (1965): 391–399.Search in Google Scholar
Reif, Stefan. Judaism and Hebrew Prayer: new perspectives on Jewish liturgical history. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 1993.10.1017/CBO9780511598180Search in Google Scholar
Richardson, Peter. Building Jewish in the Roman East. Leiden/Waco: Brill/Baylor U. P., 2004.10.1163/9789047406501Search in Google Scholar
Runesson, Anders. The Origins of the Synagogue: a socio-historical study. Stockholm: Almqvist and Wiksell International, 2001.Search in Google Scholar
Runesson, Anders. “Was there a Christian mission before the fourth century? Problematizing common ideas about early Christianity and the beginnings of modern mission.” In The Making of Christianity: conflicts, contacts, and constructions, edited by Magnus Zetterholm and Samuel Byrskog, 205–247. Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 2012.Search in Google Scholar
Rutgers, Leonard V. The Hidden Heritage of Diaspora Judaism. Leuven: Peeters, 1998.Search in Google Scholar
Schmitt, Armin. Das Buch der Weisheit: ein Kommentar. Würtzberg: Echter, 1986.Search in Google Scholar
Schwartz, Daniel R. “The Jews of Egypt between the temple of Onias, the temple of Jerusalem, and heaven.” Zion 62.1 (1997): 5–22. [in Hebrew].Search in Google Scholar
Schwartz, Seth. Imperialism and Jewish Society, 200 BCE to 640 CE. Princeton: Princeton U. P., 2001.Search in Google Scholar
Spilsbury, Paul. “Reading the Bible in Rome: Josephus and the constraints of empire.” In Josephus and Jewish History in Flavian Rome and Beyond, edited by Joseph Sievers and Gaia Lembi, 209–227. Leiden: Brill, 2005.Search in Google Scholar
Sterling, Gregory E. “‘Thus are Israel’ Jewish self-definition in Alexandria.” Studia Philonica Annual 7 (1995): 1–18.Search in Google Scholar
Tcherikover, Victor. Hellenistic Civilization and the Jews. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 1999.Search in Google Scholar
Thiessen, Matthew. Contesting Conversion: genealogy, circumcision, and identity in ancient Judaism and Christianity. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 2011.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199793563.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Tuval, Michael. “Doing without the temple: paradigms in Judaic literature of the Diaspora.” In Was 70 CE a Watershed in Jewish History?: on Jews and Judaism before and after the destruction of the Second Temple, edited by Daniel R. Schwartz and Zeev Weiss, 181–239. Leiden: Brill, 2012.Search in Google Scholar
Winston, David. Wisdom of Solomon. Garden City: Doubleday, 1979.10.5040/9780300261837Search in Google Scholar
Wiseman, Timothy P. “Lying historians: seven types of mendacity.” In Lies and Fiction in the Ancient World, edited by Christopher Gill and Timothy P. Wiseman, 122–145. Austin: University of Texas, 1993.Search in Google Scholar
Wright, Addison G. “The structure of the Book of Wisdom.” Biblica 48 (1967): 165–184.Search in Google Scholar
Zeitlin, Solomon. Studies in the Early History of Judaism. New York: Ktav, 1973.Search in Google Scholar
© 2016 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
Articles in the same Issue
- Frontmatter
- Frontmatter
- Area Review
- Herodotean Studies in the Twenty-First Century: developments and directions
- Articles
- The Madness of King Rusa: the psychology of despair in eighth century Assyria
- The Eleusinian Anaktoron of Demeter and Kore
- The Seleucid Administration of Judea, the High Priesthood and the Rise of the Hasmoneans
- Diaspora Synagogues, Leontopolis, and the Other Jewish Temples of Egypt in the Histories of Josephus
- The Case for Another Son of P. Quinctilius Varus: a re-examination of the textual and scholarly traditions around Joseph. BJ 2.68 and AJ 17.288
Articles in the same Issue
- Frontmatter
- Frontmatter
- Area Review
- Herodotean Studies in the Twenty-First Century: developments and directions
- Articles
- The Madness of King Rusa: the psychology of despair in eighth century Assyria
- The Eleusinian Anaktoron of Demeter and Kore
- The Seleucid Administration of Judea, the High Priesthood and the Rise of the Hasmoneans
- Diaspora Synagogues, Leontopolis, and the Other Jewish Temples of Egypt in the Histories of Josephus
- The Case for Another Son of P. Quinctilius Varus: a re-examination of the textual and scholarly traditions around Joseph. BJ 2.68 and AJ 17.288