Grammaticalization is generally assumed to be a gradual process and languages are thought to be grammaticalized to different degrees. For Romance languages, it has often been claimed that French is far more grammaticalized than Spanish, and that Italian occupies an intermediate position between these two. The aim of this study is to investigate to what extent this claim applies to existential constructions. In present-day French, Italian and Spanish, the most frequent existentials are il y a, c’è and hay respectively, all three being highly grammaticalized expressions. My analysis of these constructions will be based on the six parameters of grammaticalization as defined by Lehmann (1985, 1995), looking at instances drawn from a large newspaper corpus. The discussion will suggest that, as expected, French existential constructions display several signs of a highly advanced grammaticalization process which their Spanish and Italian counterparts lack. Moreover, it will be shown that the existential construction is least grammaticalized in Italian.
© 2012 by Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co.
Articles in the same Issue
- Masthead
- Introduction: The pace of grammaticalization in a typological perspective
- The pace of grammaticalization and the evolution of prepositional systems: Data from Romance
- Grammaticalisation and the internal logic of the indefinite article
- Grammaticalization and innovation in the encoding of motion events
- Word order in French, Spanish and Italian:A grammaticalization account
- Degrees of grammaticalization in three Romance languages: A comparative analysis of existential constructions
- The evolution of negation in French and Italian: Similarities and differences
- Gradualness and pace in grammaticalization: The case of adversative connectives
- Stages of grammaticalization of causative verbs and constructions in Portuguese, Spanish, French and Italian
- A comparative study of word order in Old Romance
- Possessives and grammaticalization in Romance
- Acknowledgements
- Conference report
- Index to volume 46
Articles in the same Issue
- Masthead
- Introduction: The pace of grammaticalization in a typological perspective
- The pace of grammaticalization and the evolution of prepositional systems: Data from Romance
- Grammaticalisation and the internal logic of the indefinite article
- Grammaticalization and innovation in the encoding of motion events
- Word order in French, Spanish and Italian:A grammaticalization account
- Degrees of grammaticalization in three Romance languages: A comparative analysis of existential constructions
- The evolution of negation in French and Italian: Similarities and differences
- Gradualness and pace in grammaticalization: The case of adversative connectives
- Stages of grammaticalization of causative verbs and constructions in Portuguese, Spanish, French and Italian
- A comparative study of word order in Old Romance
- Possessives and grammaticalization in Romance
- Acknowledgements
- Conference report
- Index to volume 46