Article
Licensed
Unlicensed
Requires Authentication
Comment on Raimo Tuomela. Joint Action: How Rational? How Irreducible?
-
Cédric Paternotte
Published/Copyright:
January 12, 2016
Abstract
In his ‘Cooperation as joint action’, Tuomela presents a we-mode account of cooperation, which he argues has several advantages over an individual account. This commentary examines to what extent this is true. In particular, I assess three related characteristics of we-mode joint action: its possible rationality, its greater efficiency, and its alleged irreducibility to purely individual properties, which are recurring points of the article.
Published Online: 2016-01-12
Published in Print: 2011-05-01
© 2011 by Lucius & Lucius, Stuttgart
You are currently not able to access this content.
You are currently not able to access this content.
Articles in the same Issue
- Contents
- Editorial: Work and Cooperation
- On the Logic and Ethics of Cooperation
- Potentials of Cooperation
- The Idiocy of Strategic Reasoning. Towards an Account of Consensual Action
- Comment on Hans Bernhard Schmid. Coordination, Cooperation and the Origin of Normative Expectations
- Cooperation as Joint Action
- Comment on Raimo Tuomela. Joint Action: How Rational? How Irreducible?
- Justice as Fairness and Reciprocity
- Comment on Andrew Lister. Just Distribution(s) for Mutual Recognition
- Cooperating to Promote the Good
- Comment on Robert H. Myers. Finding Out What is Substantive in Cooperation
- Reply to Anton Leist. Keeping Constructivism in Its Place
- Cooperation and Efficiency in Economic Contexts
- Cooperation for Economic Success: The Mondragon Case
- Comment on Ramon Flecha and Ignacio Santa Cruz. The Priority of Labor and Capital Accounts
- Are Multinational Companies Responsible for Working Conditions in Their Supply Chains? From Intuition to Argument
- Comment on Sonja Dänzer. Structural Injustice in Global Production Networks: Shared Responsibility for Working Conditions
- From Niche to Mass Markets: Rival Strategies in Promoting Fair Trade Organic Commodity Chains
- Recognition, Cooperation and the Moral Presuppositions of Capitalist Organization of Work
- Comment on Hermann Kocyba. The Regime of Esteem, or Recognition as Affirmation
- Fairness and Cooperation in Experimental Research
- Contractarian Compliance and the 'Sense of Justice': A Behavioral Conformity Model and Its Experimental Support
- Comment on Lorenzo Sacconi, Marco Faillo and Stefania Ottone. Contractarian Compliance, Welfarist Justice, and Conformist Utility
- Equity and Efficiency in Multi-Worker Firms: Insights from Experimental Economics
- Reciprocity in Economic Games
- Authors
Articles in the same Issue
- Contents
- Editorial: Work and Cooperation
- On the Logic and Ethics of Cooperation
- Potentials of Cooperation
- The Idiocy of Strategic Reasoning. Towards an Account of Consensual Action
- Comment on Hans Bernhard Schmid. Coordination, Cooperation and the Origin of Normative Expectations
- Cooperation as Joint Action
- Comment on Raimo Tuomela. Joint Action: How Rational? How Irreducible?
- Justice as Fairness and Reciprocity
- Comment on Andrew Lister. Just Distribution(s) for Mutual Recognition
- Cooperating to Promote the Good
- Comment on Robert H. Myers. Finding Out What is Substantive in Cooperation
- Reply to Anton Leist. Keeping Constructivism in Its Place
- Cooperation and Efficiency in Economic Contexts
- Cooperation for Economic Success: The Mondragon Case
- Comment on Ramon Flecha and Ignacio Santa Cruz. The Priority of Labor and Capital Accounts
- Are Multinational Companies Responsible for Working Conditions in Their Supply Chains? From Intuition to Argument
- Comment on Sonja Dänzer. Structural Injustice in Global Production Networks: Shared Responsibility for Working Conditions
- From Niche to Mass Markets: Rival Strategies in Promoting Fair Trade Organic Commodity Chains
- Recognition, Cooperation and the Moral Presuppositions of Capitalist Organization of Work
- Comment on Hermann Kocyba. The Regime of Esteem, or Recognition as Affirmation
- Fairness and Cooperation in Experimental Research
- Contractarian Compliance and the 'Sense of Justice': A Behavioral Conformity Model and Its Experimental Support
- Comment on Lorenzo Sacconi, Marco Faillo and Stefania Ottone. Contractarian Compliance, Welfarist Justice, and Conformist Utility
- Equity and Efficiency in Multi-Worker Firms: Insights from Experimental Economics
- Reciprocity in Economic Games
- Authors
