A Critical Discussion of the Characteristic Properties of List PR and FPTP Systems
-
Eliora van der Hout
Abstract
This paper discusses the characteristic properties of List PR systems and FPTP systems, as given in Hout 2005 and Hout et al. 2006. While many of the properties we consider are common to both systems, it turns out (see Hout 2005) that the British system distinguishes itself by satisfying the district cancellation property, while the Dutch system distinguishes itself by satisfying consistency and anonymity. For scoring rules, topsonlyness is equivalent to being party fragmentation-proof (see Hout 2005; Hout et al. 2006). One might present this as an argument in favour of requiring topsonlyness. However, we will also give counter-arguments against insisting upon the property of being party fragmentation-proof.
© 2007 by Lucius & Lucius, Stuttgart
Articles in the same Issue
- Aspiration Balancing Agreements: A New Axiomatic Approach to Bounded Rationality in Negotiations
- Choices, Norms and Preference Revelation
- Indifferences and Domain Restrictions
- Non-deteriorating Choice Without Full Transitivity
- The Shortage of Human Organs: Causes, Consequences and Remedies
- Multivariate Lorenz Majorization and Heterogeneity Measures: An Axiomatic Approach
- Living Standards and Capabilities: Equal Values or Equal Sets?
- Distributing Indivisible Goods Fairly: Evidence from a Questionnaire Study
- A Critical Discussion of the Characteristic Properties of List PR and FPTP Systems
- On Chaotic Consistent Expectations Equilibria
- On Measuring Personal Connections and the Extent of Social Networks
- Instances of Indeterminacy
- Norm-Constrained Choices
Articles in the same Issue
- Aspiration Balancing Agreements: A New Axiomatic Approach to Bounded Rationality in Negotiations
- Choices, Norms and Preference Revelation
- Indifferences and Domain Restrictions
- Non-deteriorating Choice Without Full Transitivity
- The Shortage of Human Organs: Causes, Consequences and Remedies
- Multivariate Lorenz Majorization and Heterogeneity Measures: An Axiomatic Approach
- Living Standards and Capabilities: Equal Values or Equal Sets?
- Distributing Indivisible Goods Fairly: Evidence from a Questionnaire Study
- A Critical Discussion of the Characteristic Properties of List PR and FPTP Systems
- On Chaotic Consistent Expectations Equilibria
- On Measuring Personal Connections and the Extent of Social Networks
- Instances of Indeterminacy
- Norm-Constrained Choices
