Abstract
Ever since the 2007–2008 financial crisis, the European banking sector and its regulating authorities have been seeking to revive securitization markets in Europe. The most recent attempt in this direction is the inscription of green securitization in the European sustainable finance agenda. Building on Katharina Pistor’s work on the legal coding of capital as well as Eve Chiapello’s work on financialization as a socio-technical process, our proposed contribution focuses on the legal structuring of green securitization. Based on the legal documentation and sustainability frameworks of four recent green securitization deals tied to energy-efficiency home improvements, it critically examines the new kind of financial circuits that is being constructed to channel funds towards projects deemed to create positive impacts on the environment. Our analysis shows that green securitization’s current legal structure fails to properly incorporate sustainability considerations, whether in its contractual terms, financial metrics, or parties involved.
Funding source: Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada
Award Identifier / Grant number: 430-2021-00767
References
Angeletti, T., and B. Lemoine. 2021. “The Laws of Finance for a Sociology of Finance and Law Entanglement.” European Journal of Sociology/Archives Européennes de Sociologie 62 (2): 183–212. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003975621000278.Search in Google Scholar
Association for Financial Markets in Europe (AFME). 2022. “European Green Securitisation Regulatory State of Play: Obstacles to Growth and Opportunities for Leadership.” https://www.afme.eu/Portals/0/DispatchFeaturedImages/AFME_ESGSecuritisation_2022_07_final-2.pdf.Search in Google Scholar
Banahan, C. M. 2019. “The Bond Villains of Green Investment: Why an Unregulated Securities Market Needs Government to Lay Down the Law.” Vermont Law Review 43: 841–69.Search in Google Scholar
Bavoso, V. 2017a. “High Quality Securitisation and EU Capital Markets Union – Is it Possible?” Accounting, Economics, and Law: A Convivium 7 (3): 2016008. https://doi.org/10.1515/ael-2016-0008.Search in Google Scholar
Bavoso, V. 2017b. “Filling the Accountability Gap in Structured Finance Transactions: The Case for Broader Fiduciary Obligation.” Columbia Journal of European Law 23 (2): 369–400.Search in Google Scholar
Bavoso, V. 2021. “Market-Based Finance, Debt and Systemic Risk: A Critique of the EU Capital Markets Union.” Accounting, Economics, and Law: A Convivium 11 (3): 20170039. https://doi.org/10.1515/ael-2017-0039.Search in Google Scholar
Biondi, Y. 2024. “The Forced Consumption Hypothesis.” https://tipsforthought.substack.com/p/the-forced-consumption-hypothesis.Search in Google Scholar
Bradshaw, C. 2020. “Credit Rating Agencies: Regulation and Liability.” Lewis & Clark Law Review 24 (4): 1489–526.Search in Google Scholar
Braun, B. 2020. “Central Banking and the Infrastructural Power of Finance: The Case of ECB Support for Repo and Securitization Markets.” Socio-Economic Review 18 (2): 395–418. https://doi.org/10.1093/ser/mwy008.Search in Google Scholar
Callon, M. 2006. “What Does it Mean to Say that Economics is Performative?” (Issue 005). Centre de Sociologie de l’Innovation (CSI), Mines ParisTech. https://EconPapers.repec.org/RePEc:emn:wpaper:005.Search in Google Scholar
Carruthers, B. G. 2020. “Law, Governance, and Finance: Introduction to the Theory and Society Special Issue.” Theory and Society 49: 151–64. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11186-020-09390-5.Search in Google Scholar
Cash, D. 2018. “Sustainable Finance Ratings as the Latest Symptom of ‘Rating Addiction’.” Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investment 8 (3): 242–58. https://doi.org/10.1080/20430795.2018.1437996.Search in Google Scholar
Chiapello, E. 2020a. “Financialization as a Socio-Technical Process.” In The Routledge International Handbook of Financialization, edited by P. Mader, D. Mertens, and N. van der Zwan, 81–91. Abingdon (U.K.): Routledge.10.4324/9781315142876-7Search in Google Scholar
Chiapello, E. 2020b. “Stalemate for the Financialization of Climate Policy.” Economic Sociology 22 (1): 20–9.Search in Google Scholar
Chiapello, E. 2023. “Impact Finance: How Social and Environmental Questions Are Addressed in Times of Financialized Capitalism.” Review of Evolutionary Political Economy 4: 199–220. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43253-023-00104-y.Search in Google Scholar
Chiapello, E., A. Missemer, and A. Pottier, eds. 2020. Faire l’économie de l’environnement, 39–58. Paris: Presse de l’Ecole des Mines.10.4000/books.pressesmines.6425Search in Google Scholar
Clements, R. 2020. “Misaligned Incentives in Markets: Envisioning Finance that Benefits All of Society.” DePaul Business and Commercial Law Journal 19 (1).10.2139/ssrn.3802178Search in Google Scholar
Cornut St-Pierre, P. 2023. “Securitisation from Mortgages to Sustainability: Circulating Techniques and the Financialisation of Legal Knowledge.” Transnational Legal Theory. 14 (4): 476–98. https://doi.org/10.1080/20414005.2023.2286876.Search in Google Scholar
Eggert, K. 2007. “Comment on Michael A. Stegman et al.’s “Preventive Servicing is Good for Business and Affordable Homeownership Policy”: What Prevents Loan Modifications?” Housing Policy Debate 18 (2): 279.10.1080/10511482.2007.9521601Search in Google Scholar
Eggert, K. 2009. “The Great Collapse: How Securitization Caused the Subprime Meltdown.” Connecticut Law Review 41 (4): 1257–312.Search in Google Scholar
Ekeland, I., and J. Lefournier. 2019. L’obligation verte: Homéopathie ou incantation?, working paper, Les Cahiers de la Chaire Finance & Développement Durable. https://chair-energy-prosperity.org/research-area/regulations-financieres-financements-innovants/lobligation-verte-homeopathie-incantation/.Search in Google Scholar
Engel, C. K., and P. A. McCoy. 2007. “Turning a Blind Eye: Wall Street Finance of Predatory Lending.” Fordham Law Review 75 (4): 2039–103.Search in Google Scholar
Engelen, E. 2015. “Don’t Mind the ‘Funding Gap’: What Dutch Post Crisis Storytelling Tells us About Elite Politics in Financialized Capitalism.” Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 47 (8): 1606–23. https://doi.org/10.1068/a130227p.Search in Google Scholar
Gabor, D. 2019. Securitization for Sustainability: Does it Help Achieve the Sustainable Development Goals? Heinrich Böll Stiftung. https://eu.boell.org/sites/default/files/2019-11/SecurSust.pdf.Search in Google Scholar
Garver, G. 2020. Ecological Law and the Planetary Crisis: A Legal Guide for Harmony on Earth, 1st ed. London: Routledge.10.4324/9781003019251-1Search in Google Scholar
Hughes, H. 2011. “Securitization and Suburbia.” Oregon Law Review 90 (2): 359–412.Search in Google Scholar
Jäger, J., and E. Dziwok, eds. 2024. Understanding Green Finance: A Critical Assessment and Alternative Perspectives. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.10.4337/9781803927558Search in Google Scholar
Lipson, J. 2017. “Securitization and Social Distance.” Review of Banking and Financial Law 37.Search in Google Scholar
Maltais, A., and B. Nykvist. 2021. “Understanding the Role of Green Bonds in Advancing Sustainability.” Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investments 11 (3): 233–52.Search in Google Scholar
Petit, C., and P. Schlosser. 2020. Rationale, Potential and Pitfalls of Green Securitization. Florence: European University Institute Working Papers.10.2139/ssrn.3688362Search in Google Scholar
Pistor, K. 2013. “A Legal Theory of Finance.” Journal of Comparative Economics 41 (2): 315–30. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jce.2013.03.003.Search in Google Scholar
Pistor, K. 2019. The Code of Capital: How the Law Creates Wealth and Inequality. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.10.1515/9780691189437Search in Google Scholar
Quaglia, L. 2021. “It Takes Two to Tango: The European Union and the International Governance of Securitization in Finance.” JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 59 (6): 1364–80. https://doi.org/10.1111/jcms.13227.Search in Google Scholar
Rosenow, J., and R. Galvin. 2013. “Evaluating the Evaluations: Evidence from Energy Efficiency Programmes in Germany and the UK.” Energy and Buildings 62: 450–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2013.03.021.Search in Google Scholar
Tellmann, U. 2022. “The Politics of Assetization: From Devices of Calculation to Devices of Obligation.” Distinktion: Journal of Social Theory 23 (1): 33–54. https://doi.org/10.1080/1600910X.2021.1991419.Search in Google Scholar
Wijburg, G. 2021. “The De-Financialization of Housing: Towards a Research Agenda.” Housing Studies 36 (8): 1276–93. https://doi.org/10.1080/02673037.2020.1762847.Search in Google Scholar
Case Study Documents
Fannie Mae
CICERO. 2020. “Fannie Mae Multifamily Green Bond Second Opinion.” (August 25 2020). Online (pdf).. https://capitalmarkets.fanniemae.com/.Search in Google Scholar
Fannie Mae. 2020a. “Multifamily Connecticut Avenue Securities Trust 2020-01 Offering Memorandum.” (16 March 2020).” Online (pdf). www.capitalmarkets.fanniemae.com.Search in Google Scholar
Fannie Mae. 2020b. “Multifamily Connecticut Avenue Securities Trust 2020-01 Confifential Preliminary Term Sheet.” 2020b. (2 March 2020). Online (pdf). www.capitalmarkets.fanniemae.com.Search in Google Scholar
Fannie Mae. 2021. “2020 Green Bond Impact Report Our Next Chapter in Green Bond Leadership.” Online (pdf). https://capitalmarkets.fanniemae.com/.Search in Google Scholar
Fannie Mae. 2022a. “How to: Review and Approve a Green Building Certification.” Online (pdf). https://multifamily.fanniemae.com/media/37621/display.Search in Google Scholar
Fannie Mae. 2022b. “Sustainable Bond Framework.” Online (pdf). www.capitalmarkets.fanniemae.com.Search in Google Scholar
Kensington
ISS ESG. 2021. “Second Party Opinion: Sustainability Quality of the Issuer and Green Bond Framework.” Online (pdf). www.isscorporatesolutions.com.Search in Google Scholar
Kensington. 2021a. “Finsbury Square 2021-1 Green Plc Prospectus.” (June 24 2021). Online (pdf). www.live.euronext.com. https://live.euronext.com/en/product/bonds-detail/s112656%7C27399/documents.Search in Google Scholar
Kensington. 2021b. “Green Bond Framework.” (June 2021). Online (pdf). www.isscorporatesolutions.com.Search in Google Scholar
Kensington. 2022a. “Annual Green Bond Report.” (August 2022). Online (pdf). www.isscorporatesolutions.com.Search in Google Scholar
Kensington. 2022b. “Residential Lending.” Online (pdf). www.kensingtonmortgages.co.uk.Search in Google Scholar
Obvion. 2021a. “Green Storm Prospectus.” (23 March 2021). Online (pdf). www.afm.nl.Search in Google Scholar
Obvion. 2021b. “Green Storm 2021 Green Bond Framework.” (March 2021).Search in Google Scholar
OP Mortgage Bank. 2020. “Green Covered Bond Framework.” (November 2020). Online (pdf). www.op.fi.Search in Google Scholar
OP Mortgage Bank. 2021a. “Base Prospectus: Euro Medium Term Covered Note Programme.” (2 November 2021). Online (pdf). www.op.fi.Search in Google Scholar
OP Mortgage Bank. 2021b. “Final Terms.” (23 March 2021). Online (pdf). www.op.fi.Search in Google Scholar
Rabobank. 2021a. “Sustainable Funding Framework.” (June 2021). Online (pdf). www.rabobank.com.Search in Google Scholar
Rabobank. 2021b. “Annual Report.” Online (pdf). https://www.rabobank.com/about-us/investor-relations.Search in Google Scholar
Sustainalytics. 2022. “Second-Party Opinion Obvion N.V. Green STORM.” (18 March 2022). Online (pdf). www.climatebonds.net.Search in Google Scholar
Other Materials
Climate Bonds Initiative (CBI). 2017. “Green Securitisation Unlocking Finance for Small-Scale Low Carbon Projects.” United Kingdom. https://www.climatebonds.net/files/files/March17_CBI_Briefing_Green_Securisation.pdf (accessed December 11, 2023).Search in Google Scholar
Committee on Capital Markets Regulation. 2009. “The Global Financial Crisis: A Plan for Regulatory Reform.” https://capmktsreg.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/TGFC-CCMR_Report_5-26-09.pdf.Search in Google Scholar
Eugenio Noronha Maia, I. E. N., N. J. Themeßl, and L. Kranzl. 2021. “Description of Current Energy Performance Certificates (EPCs) Related Policy Framework in Implementing Countries.” ePanacea Smart European Energy Performance Assessment & Certification. www.epanacea.eu.Search in Google Scholar
European Banking Authority (EBA). 2022. “Developing a Framework for Sustainable Securitisation.” https://www.eba.europa.eu/sites/default/documents/files/document_library/Publications/Reports/2022/1027593/EBA%20report%20on%20sustainable%20securitisation.pdf.Search in Google Scholar
Fitch Ratings. 2022. “Green and Social Securitisation: Global Momentum to Continue.” https://www.fitchratings.com/research/structured-finance/green-social-securitisation-global-momentum-to-continue-15-03-2022.Search in Google Scholar
Green Finance Observatory (GFO). 2022. “Uk’s Forthcoming Biodiversity Unit Market: Trading Permits to Destroy Nature as a Way to Protect it?” United Kingdom. https://greenfinanceobservatory.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/UK-Biodiversity-Unit-Market-2.0-1.pdf (accessed December 13, 2023).Search in Google Scholar
Hache, F. 2014. “A Missed Opportunity to Revive Boring Finance – A Policy Paper on the Capital Markets Union and STS Securitisation.” Finance Watch.Search in Google Scholar
Hache, F. 2020. “50 Shades of Green Part III. SUSTAINABLE FINANCE 2.0: The Securitization of Climate and Biodiversity Policies.” Green Finance Observatory.10.2139/ssrn.3562281Search in Google Scholar
Hay, J. 2021. “Carbon Permits – Securitization Finds a Hidden Seam.” United Kingdom: Global Capital. https://www.globalcapital.com/article/29425pg7njwqa46q9a9kw/securitization/abs/carbon-permits-securitization-finds-a-hidden-seam (accessed December 11, 2023).Search in Google Scholar
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). 2021. “WG III Contribution to the Sixth Assessment Report.” www.ipcc.ch (accessed December 11, 2023).Search in Google Scholar
International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO). 2012. “Principles for Ongoing Disclosure for Asset-Backed Securities.” Final Report. https://www.iosco.org/library/pubdocs/pdf/IOSCOpd395.pdf.Search in Google Scholar
Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS). 2020. “Energy Efficiency of the Building Stock in the EU.” https://www.rics.org/news-insights/energy-efficiency-of-the-building-stock-in-the-eu (accessed May 23, 2024).Search in Google Scholar
United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP). 2022. “2022 Global Status Report for Buildings and Construction – Towards a Zero-Emissions, Efficient and Resilient Buildings and Construction Sector.” Nairobi. https://rb.gy/sdqzvd (accessed December 11, 2023).Search in Google Scholar
United Nations Human Rights Council. 2017. “Report of the Special Rapporteur on Adequate Housing as a Component of the Right to an Adequate Standard of Living, and on the Right to Non-Discrimination in This Context.” A/HRC/34/51. https://www.ohchr.org/en/documents/thematic-reports/ahrc3451-report-special-rapporteur-adequate-housing-component-right (accessed December 30, 2024).Search in Google Scholar
© 2024 CONVIVIUM, association loi de 1901