Chapter 11. Testing the validity of Processability Theory through a corpus-based analysis
-
Yumiko Yamaguchi
Abstract
This chapter presents part of the results of a learner corpus study to test the validity of Processability Theory (PT; Pienemann, 1998, 2005). It also addresses the issues of whether second language (L2) learners are at the same PT stages for speaking and writing. The results of the analysis of spoken and written narratives by 281 Japanese learners, focusing on the acquisition of the English plural marker ‑s on nouns, have demonstrated support for the hypothesised developmental sequence for English morphology in PT. In addition, a positive relationship has been found between the learners’ spoken and written production, suggesting that PT can legitimately be used to examine L2 writing as well as speaking.
Abstract
This chapter presents part of the results of a learner corpus study to test the validity of Processability Theory (PT; Pienemann, 1998, 2005). It also addresses the issues of whether second language (L2) learners are at the same PT stages for speaking and writing. The results of the analysis of spoken and written narratives by 281 Japanese learners, focusing on the acquisition of the English plural marker ‑s on nouns, have demonstrated support for the hypothesised developmental sequence for English morphology in PT. In addition, a positive relationship has been found between the learners’ spoken and written production, suggesting that PT can legitimately be used to examine L2 writing as well as speaking.
Chapters in this book
- Prelim pages i
- Table of contents v
- Acknowledgements vii
- Chapter 1. Processability Theory, second language learning and teaching in the Asia-Pacific region 1
-
Part 1. Asian languages as second languages
- Chapter 2. Studies of Japanese as a second language and their contribution to Processability Theory 27
- Chapter 3. The development of lexical mapping in Chinese L2 63
- Chapter 4. Extending PT to split ergative marking and differential object marking 91
- Chapter 5. Acquiring content questions in Japanese child second language 115
- Chapter 6. Japanese L2 corpora and SLA research 144
-
Part 2. Bilingual first language acquisition and PT
- Chapter 7. The bilingual development of plural marking in a Malay-English child 165
- Chapter 8. Development of Japanese and English polar questions in bilingual first language acquisition 192
-
Part 3. English as Foreign Language (EFL) in Asia
- Chapter 9. Developmentally moderated focus on form in an Indonesian kindergarten EFL programme 231
- Chapter 10. The acquisition of polar questions in Chinese learners of English as a foreign language 258
- Chapter 11. Testing the validity of Processability Theory through a corpus-based analysis 280
- About the authors 301
- Index 305
Chapters in this book
- Prelim pages i
- Table of contents v
- Acknowledgements vii
- Chapter 1. Processability Theory, second language learning and teaching in the Asia-Pacific region 1
-
Part 1. Asian languages as second languages
- Chapter 2. Studies of Japanese as a second language and their contribution to Processability Theory 27
- Chapter 3. The development of lexical mapping in Chinese L2 63
- Chapter 4. Extending PT to split ergative marking and differential object marking 91
- Chapter 5. Acquiring content questions in Japanese child second language 115
- Chapter 6. Japanese L2 corpora and SLA research 144
-
Part 2. Bilingual first language acquisition and PT
- Chapter 7. The bilingual development of plural marking in a Malay-English child 165
- Chapter 8. Development of Japanese and English polar questions in bilingual first language acquisition 192
-
Part 3. English as Foreign Language (EFL) in Asia
- Chapter 9. Developmentally moderated focus on form in an Indonesian kindergarten EFL programme 231
- Chapter 10. The acquisition of polar questions in Chinese learners of English as a foreign language 258
- Chapter 11. Testing the validity of Processability Theory through a corpus-based analysis 280
- About the authors 301
- Index 305