2. Being in accordance with oneself
-
Peter J. Schulz
Abstract
It was brought to our attention that the paper “Being in accordance with oneself: Moral self-controversy in Plato and Aristotle,” by Peter J. Schulz, published in Controversies and Subjectivity, ed. Pierluigi Barrotta and Marcelo Dascal (2005): 75–90, has certain severe shortcomings in the references.John Benjamins Publishing Company endorses the statement expressed by the University of Lugano:"The survey results show that, overall, Prof. Schulz has never appropriated ideas or original research results, passing them as his own. In particular, he has never copied the entirety or essential parts of other people's publications”, it is said in today’s statement.”The complete statement can be found here.
Abstract
It was brought to our attention that the paper “Being in accordance with oneself: Moral self-controversy in Plato and Aristotle,” by Peter J. Schulz, published in Controversies and Subjectivity, ed. Pierluigi Barrotta and Marcelo Dascal (2005): 75–90, has certain severe shortcomings in the references.John Benjamins Publishing Company endorses the statement expressed by the University of Lugano:"The survey results show that, overall, Prof. Schulz has never appropriated ideas or original research results, passing them as his own. In particular, he has never copied the entirety or essential parts of other people's publications”, it is said in today’s statement.”The complete statement can be found here.
Chapters in this book
- Prelim pages i
- Table of contents v
- Acknowledgments ix
- Introduction 1
-
Part I: Discussing with oneself
- 1. Debating with myself and debating with others 33
- 2. Being in accordance with oneself 75
- 3. Conversion and controversy 91
- 4. Controversies and the logic of scientific discovery 115
- 5. Controversies and dialogic intersubjectivity 127
- 6. Disagreement, self-agreement, and self-deception 157
-
Part II: The first person
- 7. Intersubjectivity in controversy 173
- 8. Subjectivist and objectivist interpretations of controversy-based thought 185
- 9. Temporality, reification and subjectivity 201
- 10. First person singular in 17th century controversies 235
- 11. Subjective justifications 251
- 12. Early modern controversies and theories of controversy 263
- 13. Externalism, internalism, and self-knowledge 283
-
Part III: The politics of subjectivity
- 14. Liberals vs. communitarians on the self 303
- 15. Ethical implications of de-dichotomization of identities in conflict 325
- 16. The role of subjectivity in public controversy 337
- 17. The Sokal affair 353
- 18. Archaic subjectivity and/as controversy in psychoanalytic thinking 371
- The contributors to this volume 395
- Indexes 401
Chapters in this book
- Prelim pages i
- Table of contents v
- Acknowledgments ix
- Introduction 1
-
Part I: Discussing with oneself
- 1. Debating with myself and debating with others 33
- 2. Being in accordance with oneself 75
- 3. Conversion and controversy 91
- 4. Controversies and the logic of scientific discovery 115
- 5. Controversies and dialogic intersubjectivity 127
- 6. Disagreement, self-agreement, and self-deception 157
-
Part II: The first person
- 7. Intersubjectivity in controversy 173
- 8. Subjectivist and objectivist interpretations of controversy-based thought 185
- 9. Temporality, reification and subjectivity 201
- 10. First person singular in 17th century controversies 235
- 11. Subjective justifications 251
- 12. Early modern controversies and theories of controversy 263
- 13. Externalism, internalism, and self-knowledge 283
-
Part III: The politics of subjectivity
- 14. Liberals vs. communitarians on the self 303
- 15. Ethical implications of de-dichotomization of identities in conflict 325
- 16. The role of subjectivity in public controversy 337
- 17. The Sokal affair 353
- 18. Archaic subjectivity and/as controversy in psychoanalytic thinking 371
- The contributors to this volume 395
- Indexes 401
