Zum Hauptinhalt springen
Kapitel
Lizenziert
Nicht lizenziert Erfordert eine Authentifizierung

Improving the CBGM: Recent Interactions

Veröffentlichen auch Sie bei De Gruyter Brill
Erkunden Sie dieses Fachgebiet So veröffentlichen Sie bei uns
The New Testament in Antiquity and Byzantium
Ein Kapitel aus dem Buch The New Testament in Antiquity and Byzantium

Abstract

The CoherenceBased Genealogical Method (CBGM) has received a lot of attention lately due to the continued publication of the Editio Critica Maior (ECM) and the NA28/UBS5. In recent years, several extensive interactions have proffered ideas for improving the results and usability of the CBGM. In the following, I would like to address these responses and explore both their merits and feasibility. Recent publications highlight proposals for improving the CBGM, primarily concerning wishes for (1) a textual commentary, (2) including more types of witnesses, (3) modifying the procedure of regularisation, (4) creating hyparchetypes, and (5) making an interactive program and customisable version. While engaging with these proposals, I will describe which ideas might be desirable and realistic, explain the steps currently being taken by the INTF to make certain suggestions a reality, and highlight why other proposals are incompatible with the method. It is hoped that describing which tools are already available for users and what changes will be carried out in the future will offer more clarity about the method itself as well as the CBGM’s tremendous potential to elucidate genealogical relationships between Greek New Testament witnesses.

Abstract

The CoherenceBased Genealogical Method (CBGM) has received a lot of attention lately due to the continued publication of the Editio Critica Maior (ECM) and the NA28/UBS5. In recent years, several extensive interactions have proffered ideas for improving the results and usability of the CBGM. In the following, I would like to address these responses and explore both their merits and feasibility. Recent publications highlight proposals for improving the CBGM, primarily concerning wishes for (1) a textual commentary, (2) including more types of witnesses, (3) modifying the procedure of regularisation, (4) creating hyparchetypes, and (5) making an interactive program and customisable version. While engaging with these proposals, I will describe which ideas might be desirable and realistic, explain the steps currently being taken by the INTF to make certain suggestions a reality, and highlight why other proposals are incompatible with the method. It is hoped that describing which tools are already available for users and what changes will be carried out in the future will offer more clarity about the method itself as well as the CBGM’s tremendous potential to elucidate genealogical relationships between Greek New Testament witnesses.

Kapitel in diesem Buch

  1. Frontmatter I
  2. Contents V
  3. List of Contributors IX
  4. Klaus Wachtel: An Appreciation XI
  5. Klaus Wachtel: Bibliography XV
  6. A Texts
  7. The “Western” Text of Acts: A Challenge for Historians 1
  8. In anderen und eigenen Sprachen. Ein textkritisch-exegetisch motivierter Blick auf Apg 2,1–13 23
  9. Acta 2:1–22 in der Revision des Jakob von Edessa 37
  10. New Traces of an Old Text: The Corrections of Gregory-Aland 424 in Acts 1–14 51
  11. The Longer Ending of Mark in Gothic 69
  12. La géographie marcienne et ses corrections ecclésiales 81
  13. A Coptic Papyrus without John 21? 93
  14. GA 382: Byzantinisches „Allerlei“ 109
  15. The Case of the “Rule of Three” in the Gospels 123
  16. The “Power on the Head” of a Woman. A New Appraisal of 1 Corinthians 11:10 and its Variants 135
  17. The Text of Hebrews in GA 1739, in Selected Other Greek Manuscripts, and in Works of Origen: Preliminary Quantitative Assessments 147
  18. Photius: A Re-evaluation of the Johannine Evidence in Light of Modern Tools 165
  19. ὡς ἐν τῇ Ἀποκαλύψει λέγεται. (Vermeintliche) Apk-Zitate am Ende der byzantinischen Epoche 175
  20. Manuscripts of the Greek Bible 189
  21. Kr in the Gospels 203
  22. Eine Dromone in GA 013? Gedanken zu einer Schiffszeichnung 215
  23. B Editing
  24. The Earliest Printed Portions of the Greek New Testament 229
  25. Von den Evangelien bis zur Apk. Die Ordnung der Schriften in der Edition des Neuen Testaments 249
  26. Von den Kanones der Textkritik zu einer Theorie der Variantenentstehung im Rahmen der Kohärenzbasierten Genealogischen Methode. Einige vorläufige Überlegungen 265
  27. Manuscripts, Texts, History, and the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method (CBGM): Some Thoughts and Clarifications 281
  28. Improving the CBGM: Recent Interactions 295
  29. The Byzantine Text as the Initial Text 309
  30. Family 1 in the Gospel of John: Its Members, Text and the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method 325
  31. An Initial Selection of Manuscripts for the Editio Critica Maior of the Pauline Epistles 343
  32. Editorial Activity and Textual Affiliation: The Case of the Corpus Paulinum 361
  33. Die mehrheitsbildenden Gruppen der Apokalypse-Überlieferung: Textgeschichtliche und editorische Herausforderungen 385
  34. Transkription und Kollation neutestamentlicher Handschriften. Analyse der Fehlermöglichkeiten und ihrer Ursachen 401
  35. A Text-Critical Approach to Punctuation in the New Testament: 1 Corinthians 14:33 415
  36. When Does συν- Assimilate? 429
  37. Digitale Werkzeuge zur Systematisierung koptischer Handschriften 439
  38. Die Vetus Latina-Edition der Apostelgeschichte: Überlegungen zu Chronologie, Konstituierung und Disposition der „Texttypen“ 449
  39. Index of Manuscripts 467
  40. Index of Biblical Passages 473
  41. Index of Subjects 479
https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110591682-021

Kapitel in diesem Buch

  1. Frontmatter I
  2. Contents V
  3. List of Contributors IX
  4. Klaus Wachtel: An Appreciation XI
  5. Klaus Wachtel: Bibliography XV
  6. A Texts
  7. The “Western” Text of Acts: A Challenge for Historians 1
  8. In anderen und eigenen Sprachen. Ein textkritisch-exegetisch motivierter Blick auf Apg 2,1–13 23
  9. Acta 2:1–22 in der Revision des Jakob von Edessa 37
  10. New Traces of an Old Text: The Corrections of Gregory-Aland 424 in Acts 1–14 51
  11. The Longer Ending of Mark in Gothic 69
  12. La géographie marcienne et ses corrections ecclésiales 81
  13. A Coptic Papyrus without John 21? 93
  14. GA 382: Byzantinisches „Allerlei“ 109
  15. The Case of the “Rule of Three” in the Gospels 123
  16. The “Power on the Head” of a Woman. A New Appraisal of 1 Corinthians 11:10 and its Variants 135
  17. The Text of Hebrews in GA 1739, in Selected Other Greek Manuscripts, and in Works of Origen: Preliminary Quantitative Assessments 147
  18. Photius: A Re-evaluation of the Johannine Evidence in Light of Modern Tools 165
  19. ὡς ἐν τῇ Ἀποκαλύψει λέγεται. (Vermeintliche) Apk-Zitate am Ende der byzantinischen Epoche 175
  20. Manuscripts of the Greek Bible 189
  21. Kr in the Gospels 203
  22. Eine Dromone in GA 013? Gedanken zu einer Schiffszeichnung 215
  23. B Editing
  24. The Earliest Printed Portions of the Greek New Testament 229
  25. Von den Evangelien bis zur Apk. Die Ordnung der Schriften in der Edition des Neuen Testaments 249
  26. Von den Kanones der Textkritik zu einer Theorie der Variantenentstehung im Rahmen der Kohärenzbasierten Genealogischen Methode. Einige vorläufige Überlegungen 265
  27. Manuscripts, Texts, History, and the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method (CBGM): Some Thoughts and Clarifications 281
  28. Improving the CBGM: Recent Interactions 295
  29. The Byzantine Text as the Initial Text 309
  30. Family 1 in the Gospel of John: Its Members, Text and the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method 325
  31. An Initial Selection of Manuscripts for the Editio Critica Maior of the Pauline Epistles 343
  32. Editorial Activity and Textual Affiliation: The Case of the Corpus Paulinum 361
  33. Die mehrheitsbildenden Gruppen der Apokalypse-Überlieferung: Textgeschichtliche und editorische Herausforderungen 385
  34. Transkription und Kollation neutestamentlicher Handschriften. Analyse der Fehlermöglichkeiten und ihrer Ursachen 401
  35. A Text-Critical Approach to Punctuation in the New Testament: 1 Corinthians 14:33 415
  36. When Does συν- Assimilate? 429
  37. Digitale Werkzeuge zur Systematisierung koptischer Handschriften 439
  38. Die Vetus Latina-Edition der Apostelgeschichte: Überlegungen zu Chronologie, Konstituierung und Disposition der „Texttypen“ 449
  39. Index of Manuscripts 467
  40. Index of Biblical Passages 473
  41. Index of Subjects 479
Heruntergeladen am 14.5.2026 von https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110591682-021/html?lang=de
Button zum nach oben scrollen