Conflicting Commitments

Gleeson goes beyond the debate over federal immigration policy to examine the complicated terrain of immigrant worker rights.

Shannon Gleeson is Associate Professor in the School of Industrial and Labor Relations, Cornell University.

This book provides a detailed analysis of the practical dimensions of workers' labor rights in San Jose, California, and Houston, Texas.... Gleeson... offers proposals for 'making rights real' for undocumented workers and creating procedures for enforceable claims. As the study shows, the task is administratively complex and politically problematic. Summing Up: Recommended.

Agnieszka Kubal, University of Oxford:

Gleeson captivates her readers with an in-depth, intricate, and diligent ethnographic approach to the question of labor rights enforcement for undocumented immigrants in the United States... She reaffirms the hands-on approach to investigating the discrepancy between rights in theory and rights in practice by being present at official meetings, being a scrupulous reader of county council minutes, and partaking in workers' rights rallies, asembleas, and charlas organized by civil society actors... Gleeson advances an important argument in explaining the divergent policies, practices, and outcomes of migrant rights enforcement in San Jose and Houston.

Doris Marie Provine, Arizona State University, author of Unequal Under Law: Race and the War on Drugs:

Conflicting Commitments is a clearly written, insightful book that makes a convincing case for the importance of understanding local context in the enjoyment of rights. Shannon Gleeson works in the tradition of sociolegal studies, and this book is grounded in empirical investigation and focused on law as it is actually experienced by people.

Ruth Milkman, Professor of Sociology, CUNY Graduate Center; Academic Director of CUNY’s Murphy Labor Institute; and author of L.A. Story: Immigrant Workers and the Future of the U.S. Labor Movement:

Conflicting Commitments provides a fascinating comparative analysis of the political processes through which undocumented immigrant workers access their legal rights under labor and employment law in Houston and San Jose, two major U.S. immigrant gateway cities. Shannon Gleeson's approach is careful and nuanced, and the comparative methodology produces rich analytic dividends. The city-level focus is particularly timely, given the current political impasse on immigration reform at the national level and the proliferation of state and local government initiatives in this area.