Chapter
Licensed
Unlicensed
Requires Authentication
Myth 4. That Alchemy and Astrology Were Superstitious Pursuits That Did Not Contribute to Science and Scientific Understanding
-
Lawrence M. Principe
You are currently not able to access this content.
You are currently not able to access this content.
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter i
- Contents vii
- Acknowledgments xiii
- Introduction 1
-
I. Medieval and Early Modern Science
- Myth 1. That There Was No Scientific Activity between Greek Antiquity and the Scientific Revolution 7
- Myth 2. That before Columbus, Geographers and Other Educated People Thought the Earth Was Flat 16
- Myth 3. That the Copernican Revolution Demoted the Status of the Earth 23
- Myth 4. That Alchemy and Astrology Were Superstitious Pursuits That Did Not Contribute to Science and Scientific Understanding 32
- Myth 5. That Galileo Publicly Refuted Aristotle’s Conclusions about Motion by Repeated Experiments Made from the Campanile of Pisa 40
- Myth 6. That the Apple Fell and Newton Invented the Law of Gravity, Thus Removing God from the Cosmos 48
-
II. Nineteenth Century
- Myth 7. That Friedrich Wöhler’s Synthesis of Urea in 1828 Destroyed Vitalism and Gave Rise to Organic Chemistry 59
- Myth 8. That William Paley Raised Scientific Questions about Biological Origins That Were Eventually Answered by Charles Darwin 67
- Myth 9. That Nineteenth- Century Geologists Were Divided into Opposing Camps of Catastrophists and Uniformitarians 74
- Myth 10. That Lamarckian Evolution Relied Largely on Use and Disuse and That Darwin Rejected Lamarckian Mechanisms 80
- Myth 11. That Darwin Worked on His Theory in Secret for Twenty Years, His Fears Causing Him to Delay Publication 88
- Myth 12. That Wallace’s and Darwin’s Explanations of Evolution Were Virtually the Same 96
- Myth 13. That Darwinian Natural Selection Has Been “the Only Game in Town” 103
- Myth 14. That after Darwin (1871), Sexual Selection Was Largely Ignored until Robert Trivers (1972) Resurrected the Theory 112
- Myth 15. That Louis Pasteur Disproved Spontaneous Generation on the Basis of Scientific Objectivity 119
- Myth 16. That Gregor Mendel Was a Lonely Pioneer of Genetics, Being Ahead of His Time 129
- Myth 17. That Social Darwinism Has Had a Profound Influence on Social Thought and Policy, Especially in the United States of America 139
-
III. Twentieth Century
- Myth 18. That the Michelson- Morley Experiment Paved the Way for the Special Theory of Relativity 149
- Myth 19. That the Millikan Oil- Drop Experiment Was Simple and Straightforward 157
- Myth 20. That Neo- Darwinism Defines Evolution as Random Mutation Plus Natural Selection 164
- Myth 21. That Melanism in Peppered Moths Is Not a Genuine Example of Evolution by Natural Selection 171
- Myth 22. That Linus Pauling’s Discovery of the Molecular Basis of Sickle- Cell Anemia Revolutionized Medical Practice 178
- Myth 23. That the Soviet Launch of Sputnik Caused the Revamping of American Science Education 186
-
IV. Generalizations
- Myth 24. That Religion Has Typically Impeded the Progress of Science 195
- Myth 25. That Science Has Been Largely a Solitary Enterprise 202
- Myth 26. That the Scientific Method Accurately Reflects What Scientists Actually Do 210
- Myth 27. That a Clear Line of Demarcation Has Separated Science from Pseudoscience 219
- Notes 227
- Contributors 271
- Index 279
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter i
- Contents vii
- Acknowledgments xiii
- Introduction 1
-
I. Medieval and Early Modern Science
- Myth 1. That There Was No Scientific Activity between Greek Antiquity and the Scientific Revolution 7
- Myth 2. That before Columbus, Geographers and Other Educated People Thought the Earth Was Flat 16
- Myth 3. That the Copernican Revolution Demoted the Status of the Earth 23
- Myth 4. That Alchemy and Astrology Were Superstitious Pursuits That Did Not Contribute to Science and Scientific Understanding 32
- Myth 5. That Galileo Publicly Refuted Aristotle’s Conclusions about Motion by Repeated Experiments Made from the Campanile of Pisa 40
- Myth 6. That the Apple Fell and Newton Invented the Law of Gravity, Thus Removing God from the Cosmos 48
-
II. Nineteenth Century
- Myth 7. That Friedrich Wöhler’s Synthesis of Urea in 1828 Destroyed Vitalism and Gave Rise to Organic Chemistry 59
- Myth 8. That William Paley Raised Scientific Questions about Biological Origins That Were Eventually Answered by Charles Darwin 67
- Myth 9. That Nineteenth- Century Geologists Were Divided into Opposing Camps of Catastrophists and Uniformitarians 74
- Myth 10. That Lamarckian Evolution Relied Largely on Use and Disuse and That Darwin Rejected Lamarckian Mechanisms 80
- Myth 11. That Darwin Worked on His Theory in Secret for Twenty Years, His Fears Causing Him to Delay Publication 88
- Myth 12. That Wallace’s and Darwin’s Explanations of Evolution Were Virtually the Same 96
- Myth 13. That Darwinian Natural Selection Has Been “the Only Game in Town” 103
- Myth 14. That after Darwin (1871), Sexual Selection Was Largely Ignored until Robert Trivers (1972) Resurrected the Theory 112
- Myth 15. That Louis Pasteur Disproved Spontaneous Generation on the Basis of Scientific Objectivity 119
- Myth 16. That Gregor Mendel Was a Lonely Pioneer of Genetics, Being Ahead of His Time 129
- Myth 17. That Social Darwinism Has Had a Profound Influence on Social Thought and Policy, Especially in the United States of America 139
-
III. Twentieth Century
- Myth 18. That the Michelson- Morley Experiment Paved the Way for the Special Theory of Relativity 149
- Myth 19. That the Millikan Oil- Drop Experiment Was Simple and Straightforward 157
- Myth 20. That Neo- Darwinism Defines Evolution as Random Mutation Plus Natural Selection 164
- Myth 21. That Melanism in Peppered Moths Is Not a Genuine Example of Evolution by Natural Selection 171
- Myth 22. That Linus Pauling’s Discovery of the Molecular Basis of Sickle- Cell Anemia Revolutionized Medical Practice 178
- Myth 23. That the Soviet Launch of Sputnik Caused the Revamping of American Science Education 186
-
IV. Generalizations
- Myth 24. That Religion Has Typically Impeded the Progress of Science 195
- Myth 25. That Science Has Been Largely a Solitary Enterprise 202
- Myth 26. That the Scientific Method Accurately Reflects What Scientists Actually Do 210
- Myth 27. That a Clear Line of Demarcation Has Separated Science from Pseudoscience 219
- Notes 227
- Contributors 271
- Index 279