Chapter
Licensed
Unlicensed
Requires Authentication
COMPARISON IN GLOBAL HISTORY
-
Prasannan Parthasarathi
You are currently not able to access this content.
You are currently not able to access this content.
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter i
- CONTENTS vii
- PREFACE xiii
- INTRODUCTION 1
- FURTHER READING 15
-
1. WORLD HISTORY OVER TIME: The Evolution of an Intellectual and Pedagogical Movement
- INTRODUCTION 17
- THE RISE OF WORLD HISTORY SCHOLARSHIP 22
- WORLD HISTORY 39
- TOWARD WORLD HISTORY: AMERICAN HISTORIANS AND THE COMING OF THE WORLD HISTORY COURSE 48
- MARSHALL G. S. HODGSON AND THE HEMISPHERIC INTERREGIONAL APPROACH TO WORLD HISTORY 78
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 1 89
-
2. DEFINING WORLD HISTORY: Some Key Statements
- INTRODUCTION 91
- HEMISPHERIC INTERREGIONAL HISTORY AS AN APPROACH TO WORLD HISTORY 97
- THE RISE OF THE WEST AFTER TWENTY-FIVE YEARS 107
- DEPTH, SPAN, AND RELEVANCE 121
- A PLEA FOR WORLD SYSTEM HISTORY 130
- MYTHS, WAGERS, AND SOME MORAL IMPLICATIONS OF WORLD HISTORY 145
- WORLD HISTORY AND THE HISTORY OF WOMEN, GENDER, AND SEXUALITY 152
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 2 163
-
3. REGIONS IN WORLD-HISTORICAL CONTEXT
- INTRODUCTION 167
- THE MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA IN WORLD HISTORY 173
- NO LONGER ODD REGION OUT: REPOSITIONING LATIN AMERICA IN WORLD HISTORY 183
- SOUTHEAST ASIA IN WORLD HISTORY 189
- AMERICAN HISTORY AS IF THE WORLD MATTERED (AND VICE VERSA) 199
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 3 212
-
4. RETHINKING WORLD-HISTORICAL SPACE
- INTRODUCTION 215
- THE ARCHITECTURE OF CONTINENTS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE CONTINENTAL SCHEME 222
- SOUTHERNIZATION 242
- OCEANS OF WORLD HISTORY: DELINEATING AQUACENTRIC NOTIONS IN THE GLOBAL PAST 259
- ATLANTIC HISTORY: DEFINITIONS, CHALLENGES, AND OPPORTUNITIES 267
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 4 285
-
5. RETHINKING WORLD-HISTORICAL TIME
- INTRODUCTION 289
- CROSS-CULTURAL INTERACTION AND PERIODIZATION IN WORLD HISTORY 296
- WHEN DOES WORLD HISTORY BEGIN? (AND WHY SHOULD WE CARE?) 304
- HISTORY AND SCIENCE AFTER THE CHRONOMETRIC REVOLUTION 311
- WORLDING HISTORY 317
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 5 329
-
6 WORLD HISTORY AS COMPARISON
- INTRODUCTION 331
- GLOBAL AND COMPARATIVE HISTORY 335
- FRAMEWORKS FOR GLOBAL HISTORICAL ANALYSIS 337
- HOW TO WRITE THE HISTORY OF THE WORLD 342
- WHAT IS WORLD HISTORY GOOD FOR? 347
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 6 354
-
7. DEBATING THE QUESTION OF WESTERN POWER
- INTRODUCTION 357
- POLITICAL ECONOMY AND ECOLOGY ON THE EVE OF INDUSTRIALIZATION: EUROPE, CHINA, AND THE GLOBAL CONJUNCTURE 366
- THE WEST AND THE REST REVISITED: DEBATING CAPITALIST ORIGINS, EUROPEAN COLONIALISM, AND THE ADVENT OF MODERNITY 383
- CAPITALIST ORIGINS , THE ADVENT OF MODERNITY, AND COHERENT EXPLANATION: A RESPONSE TO JOSEPH M. BRYANT 399
- COMPARISON IN GLOBAL HISTORY 412
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 7 418
-
8. WORLD HISTORY, BIG HISTORY, AND THE GLOBAL ENVIRONMENT
- INTRODUCTION 421
- THE COLUMBIAN EXCHANGE 427
- MATTER MATTERS: TOWARDS A MORE “SUBSTANTIAL” GLOBAL HISTORY 434
- THE ANTHROPOCENE: ARE HUMANS NOW OVERWHELMING THE GREAT FORCES OF NATURE? 440
- BIG HISTORY: THE EMERGENCE OF A NOVEL INTERDISCIPLINARY APPROACH 459
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 8 472
-
9. GLOBAL HISTORY AND GLOBALIZATION
- INTRODUCTION 475
- GLOBAL HISTORY: APPROACHES AND NEW DIRECTIONS 484
- COMPARING GLOBAL HISTORY TO WORLD HISTORY 495
- CYCLES OF SILVER: GLOBALIZATION AS HISTORICAL PROCESS 503
- WHAT IS THE CONCEPT OF GLOBALIZATION GOOD FOR? AN AFRICAN HISTORIAN’S PERSPECTIVE 514
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 9 529
-
10. CRITIQUES AND QUESTIONS
- INTRODUCTION 533
- GLOBAL HISTORY AND CRITIQUES OF WESTERN PERSPECTIVES 540
- MUCH ADO ABOUT SOMETHING: THE NEW MALAISE OF WORLD HISTORY 555
- MYTHS, WAGERS, AND SOME MORAL IMPLICATIONS OF WORLD HISTORY 561
- BEYOND BLACKS, BONDAGE, AND BLAME: WHY A MULTICENTRIC WORLD HISTORY NEEDS AFRICA 568
- WOMEN’S AND MEN’S WORLD HISTORY? NOT YET 578
- HISTORIES FOR A LESS NATIONAL AGE 587
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 10 611
- TEACHING WORLD HISTORY, FURTHER READING 613
- CREDITS 615
- INDEX 619
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter i
- CONTENTS vii
- PREFACE xiii
- INTRODUCTION 1
- FURTHER READING 15
-
1. WORLD HISTORY OVER TIME: The Evolution of an Intellectual and Pedagogical Movement
- INTRODUCTION 17
- THE RISE OF WORLD HISTORY SCHOLARSHIP 22
- WORLD HISTORY 39
- TOWARD WORLD HISTORY: AMERICAN HISTORIANS AND THE COMING OF THE WORLD HISTORY COURSE 48
- MARSHALL G. S. HODGSON AND THE HEMISPHERIC INTERREGIONAL APPROACH TO WORLD HISTORY 78
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 1 89
-
2. DEFINING WORLD HISTORY: Some Key Statements
- INTRODUCTION 91
- HEMISPHERIC INTERREGIONAL HISTORY AS AN APPROACH TO WORLD HISTORY 97
- THE RISE OF THE WEST AFTER TWENTY-FIVE YEARS 107
- DEPTH, SPAN, AND RELEVANCE 121
- A PLEA FOR WORLD SYSTEM HISTORY 130
- MYTHS, WAGERS, AND SOME MORAL IMPLICATIONS OF WORLD HISTORY 145
- WORLD HISTORY AND THE HISTORY OF WOMEN, GENDER, AND SEXUALITY 152
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 2 163
-
3. REGIONS IN WORLD-HISTORICAL CONTEXT
- INTRODUCTION 167
- THE MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA IN WORLD HISTORY 173
- NO LONGER ODD REGION OUT: REPOSITIONING LATIN AMERICA IN WORLD HISTORY 183
- SOUTHEAST ASIA IN WORLD HISTORY 189
- AMERICAN HISTORY AS IF THE WORLD MATTERED (AND VICE VERSA) 199
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 3 212
-
4. RETHINKING WORLD-HISTORICAL SPACE
- INTRODUCTION 215
- THE ARCHITECTURE OF CONTINENTS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE CONTINENTAL SCHEME 222
- SOUTHERNIZATION 242
- OCEANS OF WORLD HISTORY: DELINEATING AQUACENTRIC NOTIONS IN THE GLOBAL PAST 259
- ATLANTIC HISTORY: DEFINITIONS, CHALLENGES, AND OPPORTUNITIES 267
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 4 285
-
5. RETHINKING WORLD-HISTORICAL TIME
- INTRODUCTION 289
- CROSS-CULTURAL INTERACTION AND PERIODIZATION IN WORLD HISTORY 296
- WHEN DOES WORLD HISTORY BEGIN? (AND WHY SHOULD WE CARE?) 304
- HISTORY AND SCIENCE AFTER THE CHRONOMETRIC REVOLUTION 311
- WORLDING HISTORY 317
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 5 329
-
6 WORLD HISTORY AS COMPARISON
- INTRODUCTION 331
- GLOBAL AND COMPARATIVE HISTORY 335
- FRAMEWORKS FOR GLOBAL HISTORICAL ANALYSIS 337
- HOW TO WRITE THE HISTORY OF THE WORLD 342
- WHAT IS WORLD HISTORY GOOD FOR? 347
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 6 354
-
7. DEBATING THE QUESTION OF WESTERN POWER
- INTRODUCTION 357
- POLITICAL ECONOMY AND ECOLOGY ON THE EVE OF INDUSTRIALIZATION: EUROPE, CHINA, AND THE GLOBAL CONJUNCTURE 366
- THE WEST AND THE REST REVISITED: DEBATING CAPITALIST ORIGINS, EUROPEAN COLONIALISM, AND THE ADVENT OF MODERNITY 383
- CAPITALIST ORIGINS , THE ADVENT OF MODERNITY, AND COHERENT EXPLANATION: A RESPONSE TO JOSEPH M. BRYANT 399
- COMPARISON IN GLOBAL HISTORY 412
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 7 418
-
8. WORLD HISTORY, BIG HISTORY, AND THE GLOBAL ENVIRONMENT
- INTRODUCTION 421
- THE COLUMBIAN EXCHANGE 427
- MATTER MATTERS: TOWARDS A MORE “SUBSTANTIAL” GLOBAL HISTORY 434
- THE ANTHROPOCENE: ARE HUMANS NOW OVERWHELMING THE GREAT FORCES OF NATURE? 440
- BIG HISTORY: THE EMERGENCE OF A NOVEL INTERDISCIPLINARY APPROACH 459
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 8 472
-
9. GLOBAL HISTORY AND GLOBALIZATION
- INTRODUCTION 475
- GLOBAL HISTORY: APPROACHES AND NEW DIRECTIONS 484
- COMPARING GLOBAL HISTORY TO WORLD HISTORY 495
- CYCLES OF SILVER: GLOBALIZATION AS HISTORICAL PROCESS 503
- WHAT IS THE CONCEPT OF GLOBALIZATION GOOD FOR? AN AFRICAN HISTORIAN’S PERSPECTIVE 514
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 9 529
-
10. CRITIQUES AND QUESTIONS
- INTRODUCTION 533
- GLOBAL HISTORY AND CRITIQUES OF WESTERN PERSPECTIVES 540
- MUCH ADO ABOUT SOMETHING: THE NEW MALAISE OF WORLD HISTORY 555
- MYTHS, WAGERS, AND SOME MORAL IMPLICATIONS OF WORLD HISTORY 561
- BEYOND BLACKS, BONDAGE, AND BLAME: WHY A MULTICENTRIC WORLD HISTORY NEEDS AFRICA 568
- WOMEN’S AND MEN’S WORLD HISTORY? NOT YET 578
- HISTORIES FOR A LESS NATIONAL AGE 587
- FURTHER READING FOR CHAPTER 10 611
- TEACHING WORLD HISTORY, FURTHER READING 613
- CREDITS 615
- INDEX 619