Irregular Migrants and the Demands of Relational Equality
-
Diego Tapia-Riquelme
Abstract
Should states naturalize long-term irregular migrants residing in their territory? Scholars such as Carens and Rubio-Marín have defended their naturalization by drawing on a theory of social membership. However, some have argued that the social membership account falls short of requiring the granting of citizenship to irregular migrants. Others, such as Brock, Ochoa Espejo, and Hosein, have attempted to defend a right not to be deported. I argue that relational equality can provide a defense for granting irregular migrants citizenship rights – their complete naturalization – which avoids the limitations of both approaches: it provides a more solid grounding for granting citizenship to irregular migrants, and shows why a right to stay still leaves irregular migrants in a morally troubling position. Irregular migrants are subjected for long periods of time to the laws of the state they reside in without having any power or influence over them and face significant difficulties in leaving the country, which results in objectionable social inequality. I argue that such concerns about inequality of status override the right of the demos to determine its membership and concerns about irregular migrants’ original breaking of the law.
Acknowledgments
I thank George Klosko, Sam Koreman, Ross Mittiga, Alexander Motchoulski, Jen Rubenstein, Daniel Sharp, and two anonymous reviewers for incredibly helpful comments on earlier drafts of this article.
References
Abizadeh, Arash. 2008. “Democratic Theory and Border Coercion: No Right to Unilaterally Control Your Own Borders.” Political Theory 36 (1): 37–65. https://doi.org/10.1177/0090591707310090.Search in Google Scholar
Abizadeh, Arash. 2010. “Democratic Legitimacy and State Coercion: A Reply to David Miller.” Political Theory 38 (1): 121–30. https://doi.org/10.1177/0090591709348192.Search in Google Scholar
Abizadeh, Arash. 2012. “On the Demos and its Kin: Nationalism, Democracy, and the Boundary Problem.” American Political Science Review 106 (4): 867–82, https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055412000421.Search in Google Scholar
Abizadeh, Arash. 2021. “The Scope of the All-Subjected Principle: On the Logical Structure of Coercive Laws.” Analysis 81 (4): 603–10, https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/anab041.Search in Google Scholar
Anderson, Elizabeth S. 1999. “What Is the Point of Equality?” Ethics 109 (2): 287–337. https://doi.org/10.1086/233897.Search in Google Scholar
Angeleri, Stefano. 2022. Irregular Migrants and the Right to Health. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/9781009051750Search in Google Scholar
Baker, Bryan. 2021. Estimates of the Unauthorized Immigrant Population Residing in the United States: January 2015–January 2018. Issue January. https://www.dhs.gov/immigration-statistics/population-estimates/unauthorized-resident (accessed October 1, 2023).Search in Google Scholar
Bauböck, Rainer. 2018. Democratic Inclusion: Rainer Bauböck in Dialogue. Manchester: Manchester University Press.10.7765/9781526105257Search in Google Scholar
Bender, Felix. 2021. “Enfranchising the Disenfranchised: Should Refugees Receive Political Rights in Liberal Democracies?” Citizenship Studies 25 (1): 56–71, https://doi.org/10.1017/S1752971916000105.Search in Google Scholar
Blake, Michael. 2010. “Equality without Documents: Political Justice and the Right to Amnesty.” Canadian Journal of Philosophy 2014 (supp 1): 99–122. https://doi.org/10.1080/00455091.2010.10717656.Search in Google Scholar
Blake, Michael. 2020. Justice, Migration, and Mercy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780190879556.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Brock, Gillian. 2020. Justice for People on the Move: Migration in Challenging Times. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/9781108774581Search in Google Scholar
Carens, Joseph H. 2013. The Ethics of Immigration. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Cohen, Elizabeth F. 2020. Illegal: How America’s Lawless Immigration Regime Threatens Us All. New York: Basic Books.Search in Google Scholar
Fiss, Owen. 1999. A Community of Equals: The Constitutional Protection of New Americans, edited by Joshua Cohen, and Joel Rogers. Boston: Beacon Press.Search in Google Scholar
Fourie, Carina. 2012. “What Is Social Equality? an Analysis of Status Equality as a Strongly Egalitarian Ideal.” Res Publica 18 (2): 107–26. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11158-011-9162-2.Search in Google Scholar
Fourie, Carina, Frank Schuppert, and Ingmar Wilhelm-Helmer. 2015. Social Equality: On What it Means to Be Equals. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199331109.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Gonzalez-Barrera, Ana, and Philip Connor. 2019. Around the World, More Say Immigrants Are a Strength than a Burden. Issue March. https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2019/03/14/around-the-world-more-say-immigrants-are-a-strength-than-a-burden/ (accessed October 1, 2023).Search in Google Scholar
Goodin, Robert. 2016. “Enfranchising All Subjected, Worldwide.” International Theory 8 (3): 365–89, https://doi.org/10.1017/S1752971916000105.Search in Google Scholar
Hacker, Karen, M. Anies, B. L. Folb, and L. Zallman. 2015. “Barriers to Health Care for Undocumented Immigrants: A Literature Review.” Risk Management and Healthcare Policy 8: 175–83. https://doi.org/10.2147/RMHP.S70173.Search in Google Scholar
Hosein, A. O. 2014. “Immigration: The Argument for Legalization.” Social Theory and Practice 40 (4): 609–30. https://doi.org/10.5840/soctheorpract201440436.Search in Google Scholar
Jensen, K. K., and L. Nielsen. 2021. “Reconciling Automatic and Conditional Immigrant Naturalisation.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 47 (1): 208–26. https://doi.org/10.1080/1369183X.2019.1614437.Search in Google Scholar
Karlsen, Marry-Anne. 2021. Migration Control and Access to Welfare: The Precarious Inclusion of Irregular Migrants in Norway. Abingdon: Routledge.10.4324/9781003156598Search in Google Scholar
Kolodny, Niko. 2014. “Rule over None II: Social Equality and the Justification of Democracy.” Philosophy & Public Affairs 42 (4): 287–336, https://doi.org/10.1111/papa.12037.Search in Google Scholar
Kolodny, Niko. 2023. The Pecking Order: Social Hierarchy as a Philosophical Problem. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.10.4159/9780674292819Search in Google Scholar
Lenard, Patti. 2023. Democracy and Exclusion. New York: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780197585818.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Miller, David. 2010. “Why Immigration Controls Are Not Coercive: A Reply to Arash Abizadeh.” Political Theory 38 (1): 111–20. https://doi.org/10.1177/0090591709348194.Search in Google Scholar
Miller, David. 2016. Strangers in Our Midst: The Political Philosophy of Immigration. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.10.4159/9780674969827Search in Google Scholar
Motchoulski, A. 2021. “Relational Egalitarianism and Democracy.” Journal of Moral Philosophy 18 (6): 620–49. https://doi.org/10.1163/17455243-20213471.Search in Google Scholar
Oberman, Kevin. 2017. “Immigration, Citizenship, and Consent: What Is Wrong with Permanent Alienage?” Journal of Political Philosophy 25 (1): 91–107. https://doi.org/10.1111/jopp.12093.Search in Google Scholar
Ochoa Espejo, Paulina. 2016. “Taking Place Seriously: Territorial Presence and the Rights of Immigrants.” Journal of Political Philosophy 24 (1): 67–87, https://doi.org/10.1111/jopp.12061.Search in Google Scholar
Ochoa Espejo, Paulina. 2020. On Borders: Territories, Legitimacy, and the Rights of Place. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780190074197.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Pevnick, Ryan. 2011. Immigration and the Constraints of Justice: Between Open Borders and Absolute Sovereignty. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511975134Search in Google Scholar
Reed-Sandoval, Amy. 2020. Socially Undocumented: Identity and Immigration Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780190619800.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Rubio-Marín, Ruth. 2000. Immigration as a Democratic Challenge: Citizenship and Inclusion in Germany and the United States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511491122Search in Google Scholar
Scheffler, Samuel. 2003. “What Is Egalitarianism?” Philosophy & Public Affairs 31 (1): 5–39, https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1088-4963.2003.00005.x.Search in Google Scholar
Schon, Justin, and David Leblang. 2021. “Why Physical Barriers Backfire: How Immigration Enforcement Deters Return and Increases Asylum Applications.” Comparative Political Studies 54 (14): 2611–52, https://doi.org/10.1177/00104140211024282.Search in Google Scholar
Seglow, Jonathan. 2009. “Arguments for Naturalisation.” Political Studies 57 (4): 788–804. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9248.2008.00768.x.Search in Google Scholar
Sharp, Daniel. 2022. “Relational Equality and Immigration.” Ethics 132 (3): 644–79, https://doi.org/10.1086/718076.Search in Google Scholar
Sharp, Daniel. 2023. “Immigration, Naturalization, and the Purpose of Citizenship.” Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 104 (2): 408–41, https://doi.org/10.1111/papq.12428.Search in Google Scholar
Song, Sarah. 2009. “Democracy and Noncitizen Voting Rights.” Citizenship Studies 13 (6): 607–20. https://doi.org/10.1080/13621020903309607.Search in Google Scholar
Song, Sarah. 2016. “The Significance of Territorial Presence and the Rights of Immigrants.” In Migration in Political Theory, edited by Sarah Fine, and Lea Ypi, 225–48. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Song, Sarah. 2019. Immigration and Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780190909222.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Triandafyllidou, Anna. 2016. “Irregular Migrant Domestic Workers in Europe: Who Cares?” In Irregular Migrant Domestic Workers in Europe: Who Cares?, edited by A. Triandafyllidou. Abingdon: Routledge.10.4324/9781315589831Search in Google Scholar
United Nations. 2014. Cultural Rights of Migrants. United Nations. https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Publications/HR-PUB-14-1_en.pdf (accessed September 3, 2023).Search in Google Scholar
Viehoff, Daniel. 2014. “Democratic Equality and Political Authority.” Philosophy & Public Affairs 42 (4): 337–75, https://doi.org/10.1111/papa.12036.Search in Google Scholar
Viehoff, Daniel. 2019. “Power and Equality.” In Oxford Studies in Political Philosophy, edited by David Sobel, Peter Vallentyne, and Steven Wall, 3–38. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780198841425.003.0001Search in Google Scholar
Walzer, Michael. 1983. Spheres of Justice: A Defense of Pluralism and Equality. New York: Basic Books.Search in Google Scholar
Wellman, Christopher Heath, and Philip Cole. 2011. Debating the Ethics of Migration: Is There a Right to Exclude? Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/acprof:osobl/9780199731732.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
© 2024 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
