Abstract
Adjective order restrictions on attributive adjectives (AORs) have been subject to debate in modern linguistic research for a long time. Most generally, the question whether AORs can be located in grammar as such in rule-based fashion is still unsettled. In the current paper, we largely argue against this view and claim that several of the core data to be explained are preferences based on norms rather than rules. A pragmatic explanation is offered to account for marked or apparently ungrammatical examples. First, we demarcate AORs in the narrow sense against data based on truth-conditional differences, show the sole hard constraint to be found in a distinction between object- and kind-modification, and introduce several of the factors argued to drive AORs in the literature. A large-scale corpus study on German AAN-phrases shows a hierarchy of relative adjectives preceding absolute ones to reliably predict preferences, while temporariness and weight do not. We then illustrate that norm-based preferences can be overwritten via discourse linking and implement markedness in out-of-the-blue contexts pragmatically based on the M-principle. Speculating that AORs in the narrow sense have their origins in more general cognitive principles, our findings support approaches that locate the better part of AORs outside the realm of core grammar.
References
Adam, Séverine & Michael Schecker. 2011. Position und Funktion: Kognitive Aspekte der Abfolge attributiver Adjektive. In Günter Schmale (ed.), Das Adjektiv im heutigen Deutsch. Syntax, Semantik, Pragmatik (=Eurogermanistik 29), 157–172. Tübingen: Stauffenburg.Search in Google Scholar
Arsenijević, Boban, Gemma Boleda, Berit Gehrke & Louise McNally. 2014. Ethnic adjectives are proper adjectives. In Rebekah B. Baglini, Timothy Grinsell, Jonathan Keane & Julia Thomas (eds.), Proceedings of CLS 46, 17–30. Chicago: The Chicago Linguistic Society.Search in Google Scholar
Asher, Nicholas. 2004. Discourse topic. Theoretical Linguistics 30(2–3). 163–201.10.1515/thli.2004.30.2-3.163Search in Google Scholar
Asher, Nicholas & Alex Lascarides. 2003. Logics of conversation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Bache, Carl & Niels Davidsen-Nielsen. 1997. Mastering English. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.10.1515/9783110803181Search in Google Scholar
Behaghel, Otto. 1909. Beziehungen zwischen Umfang und Reihenfolge von Satzgliedern. Indogermanische Forschungen 25. 110–142.Search in Google Scholar
Bouchard, Denis. 2002. Adjectives, number and interfaces: Why languages vary. Amsterdam: Elsevier.10.1163/9780585475219Search in Google Scholar
Bouchard, Denis. 2011. Review: Syntax: Cinque (2010). Linguist List book reviewhttps://linguistlist.org/issues/22/22-2513.html (June 20, 2016).10.1016/B978-1-4160-5473-3.00004-6Search in Google Scholar
Carlson, Greg N. 1980. Reference to kinds in English. New York/London: Garland Publishing.Search in Google Scholar
Carlson, Greg N. 2003. Interpretive asymmetries in major phrases. In Anna Maria Di Sciullo (ed.), Asymmetry in grammar: Syntax and semantics, 301–314. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.10.1075/la.57.14carSearch in Google Scholar
Champollion, Lucas. 2006. A game-theoretic account of adjective ordering restrictions. University of Pennsylvania manuscript, 1–16.http://ling.upenn.edu/~champoll/adjective-ordering.pdf (July 1, 2016).Search in Google Scholar
Cinque, Guglielmo. 1994. On the evidence for partial N-movement in the Romance DP. In Guglielmo Cinque, Jan Koster, Jean-Yves Pollock, Luigi Rizzi & Raffaella Zanuttini (eds.), Paths towards universal grammar. Studies in honor of Richard S. Kayne, 85–110. Washington D.C.: Georgetown University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Cinque, Guglielmo. 2010. The syntax of adjectives. A comparative study. Cambridge, MA/London: MIT Press.10.7551/mitpress/9780262014168.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Cooper, William E. & John R. Ross. 1975. World order. In Robin E. Grossman, L. James Sam & Timothy J. Vance (eds.), Papers from the Parasession on Functionalism, 63–111. Chicago: Chicago Linguistic Society.Search in Google Scholar
D’Avis, Franz. 2013. Normalität und Sprache - Normalvorstellungen und ihre Rolle in bestimmten Konstruktionen des Deutschen. Mainz, Germany: Johannes Gutenberg Universität habilitation treatise.Search in Google Scholar
Dixon, Robert M. W. 1982. Where have all the adjectives gone? And other essays in semantics and syntax. Berlin: De Gruyter.10.1515/9783110822939Search in Google Scholar
Eichinger, Ludwig M. 1991. Woran man sich halten kann: Grammatik und Gedächtnis. Jahrbuch Deutsch als Fremdsprache 17. 203–220.Search in Google Scholar
Eichinger, Ludwig M. 1992. Ganz natürlich – Aber im Rahmen bleiben. Zur Reihenfolge gestufter Adjektivattribute. Deutsche Sprache 4(91). 312–329.Search in Google Scholar
Eroms, Hans-Werner. 2000. Syntax der deutschen Sprache. Berlin: de Gruyter.10.1515/9783110808124Search in Google Scholar
Fernald, Theodore B. 2000. Predicates and temporal arguments. New York/Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780195114355.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Gunkel, Lutz & Gisela Zifonun. 2009. Classifying modifiers in common names. Word Structure 2(2). 205–218.10.3366/E1750124509000415Search in Google Scholar
Halliday, Michael A. K. 2014. Halliday’s introduction to Functional Grammar 4th edn revised by Christian Matthiessen. London: Routledge.10.4324/9780203783771Search in Google Scholar
Härtl, Holden. 2016. Normality at the boundary between word-formation and syntax. In Franz d’ Avis & Horst Lohnstein (eds.), Normalität in der Sprache (=Linguistische Berichte Sonderhefte 22), 71–98. Hamburg: Buske.Search in Google Scholar
Hetzron, Robert. 1978. On the relative order of adjectives. In Hansjakob Seiler (ed.), Language Universals, Papers from the Conference held at Gummersbach/ Cologne,Germany, October 3–8, 1976, 165–184. Tübingen: Narr.Search in Google Scholar
Hobbs, Jerry R. 1979. Coherence and coreference. Cognitive Science 3(1). 67–90.10.1207/s15516709cog0301_4Search in Google Scholar
Jäger, Gerhard. 2001. Topic-comment structure and the contrast between stage level and individual level predicates. Journal of Semantics 18(2). 83–126.10.1093/jos/18.2.83Search in Google Scholar
Kamp, Hans. 1975. Two theories about adjectives. In Edward L. Keenan (ed.), Formal semantics of natural language, 123–155. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511897696.011Search in Google Scholar
Kennedy, Christopher. 2007. Vagueness and grammar: The semantics of relative and absolute gradable adjectives. Linguistics and Philosophy 30(1). 1–45.10.1007/s10988-006-9008-0Search in Google Scholar
Kennedy, Christopher & Louise McNally. 2005. Scale structure, degree modification, and the semantics of gradable predicates. Language 81. 345–381.10.1353/lan.2005.0071Search in Google Scholar
Khemlani, Sangeet, Sarah-Jane Leslie, Sam Glucksberg & Paula Rubio-Fernandez. 2007. Do ducks lay eggs? How people interpret generic assertions. In Danielle S. McNamara & J. Greg Trafton (eds.), Proceedings of the 29th Annual Cognitive Science Society Austin, 395–400. TX: Cognitive Science Society.Search in Google Scholar
King, Jonathan W. & Marta Kutas. 1995. Who did what to when?: Using word- and clause-level ERPs to monitor working memory usage in reading. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 7(3). 376–395.10.1162/jocn.1995.7.3.376Search in Google Scholar
Kotowski, Sven. 2016. Adjectival modification and order restrictions. The influence of temporariness on prenominal word order (=Studia Grammatica 80). Berlin: de Gruyter.10.1515/9783110478457Search in Google Scholar
Kotowski, Sven & Holden Härtl. 2011. Recursion and the language faculty. On the evolution of the concept in generative grammar. In Said Sahel & Ralf Vogel (eds.), NLK-Proceedings: 12. Norddeutsches Linguistisches Kolloquium (NLK2011 Braunschweig), 24–47. Bielefeld: Bielefeld eCollections.Search in Google Scholar
Kratzer, Angelika. 1995. Stage-level and individual-level predicates. In Gregory N. Carlson & Francis J. Pelletier (eds.), The Generic Book, 125–175. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.Search in Google Scholar
Kulakova, Eugenia, Dominik Freunberger & Dietmar Roehm. 2014. Marking the counterfactual: ERP evidence for pragmatic processing of German subjunctives. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 8.http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fnhum.2014.00548 (December 5, 2016).10.3389/fnhum.2014.00548Search in Google Scholar
Laenzlinger, Christopher. 2005. French adjective ordering: Perspectives on DP-internal movement types. Lingua 115. 645–689.10.1016/j.lingua.2003.11.003Search in Google Scholar
Larson, Richard K. 1998. Events and Modification in Nominals. In Devon Strolovitch & Aaron Lawson (eds.), Proceedings from Semantics and Linguistic Theory (SALT) VIII, 145–168. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University.10.3765/salt.v8i0.2803Search in Google Scholar
Leslie, Sarah-Jane. 2008. Generics: Cognition and acquisition. The Philosophical Review 117(1). 1–49.10.1215/00318108-2007-023Search in Google Scholar
Levi, Judith. 1978. The syntax and semantics of complex nominals. New York: Academic Press.Search in Google Scholar
Levinson, Stephen C. 2000. Presumptive meanings: The theory of generalized conversational implicature. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.10.7551/mitpress/5526.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Maienborn, Claudia. 2003. Die logische Form von Kopula-Sätzen (=Studia Grammatica 56). Berlin: Akademie Verlag.10.1524/9783050082271Search in Google Scholar
McNally, Louise & Gemma Boleda. 2004. Relational adjectives as properties of kinds. In Olivier Bonami & Patricia Cabredo Hofherr (eds.), Empirical Issues in Syntax and Semantics Vol. 5, 179–196.Search in Google Scholar
Published only electronically: http://www.cssp.cnrs.fr/eiss5/mcnally-boleda/mcnally-boleda-eiss5.pdf (accessed 05 January 2019)Search in Google Scholar
Motsch, Wolfgang. 2002. Die Wortart ‘Adjektiv’. In D. Alan Cruse, Franz Hundsnurscher, Michael Job & Peter Rolf Lutzeier (eds.), Lexikologie. Ein internationales Handbuch zur Natur und Struktur von Wörtern und Wortschätzen (1st sub-vol.), 598–604. Berlin: de Gruyter.Search in Google Scholar
Motsch, Wolfgang. 2004. Deutsche Wortbildung in Grundzügen. 2nd ed. Berlin: de Gruyter.10.1515/9783110906059Search in Google Scholar
Partee, Barbara H. 1995. Lexical semantics and compositionality. In Daniel Osherson, Lila Gleitman & Mark Liberman, (eds.), Invitation to cognitive science. Part I: Language, 311–360. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Search in Google Scholar
Payne, John & Rodney Huddleston. 2002. Nouns and noun phrases. In Rodney Huddleston & Geoffrey K. Pullum (eds.), The Cambridge grammar of the English language, 323–523. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/9781316423530.006Search in Google Scholar
Posner, Roland. 1980. Ikonismus in der Syntax. Zur natürlichen Stellung der Attribute. Zeitschrift für Semiotik 2. 57–82.Search in Google Scholar
R. Harald, Baayen, Victor Kuperman & Raymond Bertram. 2010. Frequency effects in compound processing. In Sergio Scalise & Irene Vogel (eds.), Cross-Disciplinary Issues in Compounding, 257–270. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.10.1075/cilt.311.20baaSearch in Google Scholar
Ramaglia, Francesca. 2011. Adjectives at the syntax-semantics interface. München: Lincom Europa.Search in Google Scholar
Reinhart, Tanja. 1980. Conditions for text coherence. Poetics Today 1(4). 161–180.10.2307/1771893Search in Google Scholar
Rijkhoff, Jan. 2002. The noun phrase. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198237822.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Rijkhoff, Jan. 2010. Functional categories in the noun phrase: On jacks-of-all-trades and one-trick-ponies in Danish, Dutch and German. Deutsche Sprache 2. 97–124.10.37307/j.1868-775X.2010.02.03Search in Google Scholar
Rotstein, Carmen & Yoad Winter. 2004. Total adjectives vs. partial adjectives: Scale structure and higher-order modifiers. Natural Language Semantics 12(3). 259–288.10.1023/B:NALS.0000034517.56898.9aSearch in Google Scholar
Schlücker, Barbara. 2014. Grammatik im Lexikon. Adjektiv-Nomen-Verbindungen im Deutschen und Niederländischen (=Linguistische Arbeiten 553). Berlin & Boston: de Gruyter.10.1515/9783110347838Search in Google Scholar
Schlücker, Barbara & Ingo Plag. 2011. Compound or phrase? Analogy in naming. Lingua 121. 539–551.10.1016/j.lingua.2011.04.005Search in Google Scholar
Schurz, Gerhard. 2001. What is ‘normal’? An evolution-theoretic foundation for normic laws and their relation to statistical normality. Philosophy of Science 68(4). 476–497.10.1086/392938Search in Google Scholar
Scontras, Gregory, Judith Degen & Noah D. Goodman. 2017. Subjectivity predicts adjective ordering preferences. Open Mind 1. 53–65.10.1162/OPMI_a_00005Search in Google Scholar
Scott, Gary-John. 2002. Stacked adjectival modification and the structure of nominal phrases. In Guglielmo Cinque (ed.), Functional structure in the DP and IP: The cartography of syntactic structures (vol. I), 91–120. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780195148794.003.0004Search in Google Scholar
Seiler, Hansjakob. 1978. Determination: A functional dimension for interlanguage comparison. In Hansjakob Seiler (ed.), Language Universals, Papers from the Conference held at Gummersbach/ Cologne,Germany, October 3–8, 1976, 301–328. Tübingen: Narr.Search in Google Scholar
Solt, Stephanie. 2016. Ordering subjectivity and the absolute/relative distinction. In Nadine Bade, Polina Berezovskaya & Anthea Schöller (eds.), Proceedings of Sinn und Bedeutung Vol. 20, 676–693.Search in Google Scholar
Published only electronically: https://semanticsarchive.net/sub2015/SeparateArticles/Solt-SuB20.pdf (accessed 05 January 2019)Search in Google Scholar
Sproat, Richard & Chilin Shih. 1988. Prenominal adjectival ordering in English and Mandarin. In James Blevins & Juli Carter (eds.), Proceedings of NELS 18, 465–489. Amherst, MA: GLSA.Search in Google Scholar
Svenonius, Peter. 1994. The Structural location of the attributive adjective. In Eric Duncan, Donka Farkas & Philip Spaelti (eds.), Proceedings of WCCFL 12, 429–454. Stanford: CSLI Publications.Search in Google Scholar
Svenonius, Peter. 2008. The position of adjectives and other phrasal modifiers in the decomposition of DP. In Louise McNally & Chris Kennedy (eds.), Adjectives and adverbs: Syntax, semantics, and discourse, 16–42. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780199211616.003.0002Search in Google Scholar
Teodorescu, Alexandra. 2006. Adjective ordering restrictions revisited. In Donald Baumer, David Montero & Michael Scanlon (eds.), Proceedings of the 25th West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, 399–407. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.Search in Google Scholar
Trost, Igor. 2006. Das deutsche Adjektiv. Hamburg: Buske.Search in Google Scholar
Truswell, Robert. 2009. Attributive adjectives and nominal templates. Linguistic Inquiry 40. 525–533.10.1162/ling.2009.40.3.525Search in Google Scholar
Van der Hulst, Harry. 2010. Re recursion. In Harry van der Hulst (ed.), Recursion in Human Language, xv–liii. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter.10.1515/9783110219258Search in Google Scholar
Vendler, Zeno 1968. Adjectives and nominalizations. The Hague: Mouton & Co.Search in Google Scholar
Vergnaud, Jean-Roger & Maria Luisa Zubizarreta. 1992. The definite determiner and the inalienable constructions in French and English. Linguistic Inquiry 23(4). 595–652.Search in Google Scholar
Zifonun, Gisela, Ludger Hoffmann & Bruno Strecker. 1997. Grammatik der deutschen Sprache. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter.10.1515/9783110872163Search in Google Scholar
© 2019 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
Articles in the same Issue
- Frontmatter
- Long-standing issues in adjective order and corpus evidence for a multifactorial approach
- Linear vs. hierarchical: Two accounts of premodification in the of-binominal noun phrase
- A cognitive-functional approach to the order of adjectives in the English noun phrase
- Adjective orders in Cimbrian DPs
- How real are adjective order constraints? Multiple prenominal adjectives at the grammatical interfaces
Articles in the same Issue
- Frontmatter
- Long-standing issues in adjective order and corpus evidence for a multifactorial approach
- Linear vs. hierarchical: Two accounts of premodification in the of-binominal noun phrase
- A cognitive-functional approach to the order of adjectives in the English noun phrase
- Adjective orders in Cimbrian DPs
- How real are adjective order constraints? Multiple prenominal adjectives at the grammatical interfaces