The Constitutional Relevance of the ECHR in Domestic Law: The Kosovo Perspective

References

Austria’s Constitution of 1920, reinstated in 1945, with Amendments through 2013, available at: <https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Austria_2013>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Blackburn, Robert, “The Institutions and Processes of the Convention,” in R. Blackburn, & J. Polakiewicz (eds.), Fundamental Rights in Europe: The ECHR and its Member States 1950–2000, (Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press, 2001).10.1093/oso/9780199243488.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Bytyci, Fatos, Kosovo hopes to join Council of Europe after Russia’s exit, Reuters, available at: <https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/kosovo-hopes-join-council-europe-after-russias-exit-2022-05-12/>, accessed November 26, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Case against Arben Krasniqi et al.., Case No. P 425/11 [2012], available at: <https://www.eulex-kosovo.eu/docs/justice/judgments/criminal-proceedings/DCPrishtina/425-11-Klecka/PristDC%20P%20425-11%20Arben%20Krasniqi%20et%20al%20(Klecka%20-%201)_Judgment%2030.03.12_%20redacted.pdf>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Case no. KI207/19, available at: <https://gjk-ks.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/ki_207_19_agj_ang.pdf>, accessed September 7, 2022.Search in Google Scholar

Case No. KO 47/10, Naim Rrustemi and 31 other Deputies of the Assembly of the Republic of Kosovo against Fatmir Sejdiu, President of the Republic of Kosovo, available at: <https://gjk-ks.org/en/decision/naim-rrustemi-and-31-other-deputies-of-the-assembly-of-the-republic-of-kosovo-vs-his-excellency-fatmir-sejdiu-president-of-the-republic-of-kosovo/>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Chanturia, Lado, The Application of the European Convention on Human Rights and Judicial Dialogue, Journal of Law, no. 2 (2019).Search in Google Scholar

Cemailj Kurtisi against the Municipal Assembly of Prizren , Case No. KO 01/09 [2010], available <https://gjk-ks.org/en/decision/qemajl-kurtishi-dhe-kuvendi-komunal-i-prizrenit/>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Constitution of the Republic of Kosovo (2008), available at: <https://gzk.rks-gov.net/ActDocumentDetail.aspx?ActID=3702>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Constitutional Court, Annual Report 2019, available at: <https://gjk-ks.org/p-content/uploads/2020/08/raporti_vjetor_gjkk_2019_ang.pdf>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Constitutional Court, Annual Report 2020, available at: <https://gjk-ks.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/rv_2020_gjkk_ang.pdf>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Constitutional Court, Annual Report 2021, available at: <https://gjk-ks.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Raporti-vjetor-2021_ang.pdf>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo, Judgment KO 04/11, available at: <https://gjk-ks.org/wp-content/uploads/vendimet/gjk_ko_04_11_ang.pdf>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kosovo, Judgment K.O. 29/12 and K.O. 48/12, paragraph 63, 2012, available at: <https://gjk-ks.org/wp content/uploads/vendimet/Aktgjykim%20Anex%20A&B%20KO29_48_12_ANG.pdf>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Dicosola, Maria, et al.., The Prospective Role of Constitutional Courts in the Advisory Opinion Mechanism Before the European Court of Human Rights: A First Comparative Assessment with the European Union and the Inter-American System, 16 German Law Journal, no. 6 (2015).10.1017/S2071832200021192Search in Google Scholar

European Commission on Democracy Through Law (Venice Commission), Report on Case Law Regarding the Supremacy of International Human Rights Treaties (Strasbourg, October 22, 2004), available at: <https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/default.aspx?pdffile=CDL-DI(2004)005rev-e>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

European Court of Human Rights, HUDOC, available at: <http://hudoc.echr.coe.int>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Fan Jizeng, Barrett, Convergence, Compatibility or Decoration: The Luxembourg Court’s References to Strasbourg Case Law in its Final Judgments, Pécs Journal of International and European Law, no. 2 (2016).Search in Google Scholar

Fitzmaurice, Malgosia and Merkouris, Panos (eds.), The Interpretation and Application of the European Convention of Human Rights: Legal and Practical Implications, (Part Two, Implications of the European Convention of Human Rights in Specific Areas of International law) (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2013).10.1163/9789004242838Search in Google Scholar

Gerards, Janneke and Fleuren, Joseph, (eds.), Implementation of The European Convention on Human Rights and of the Judgments of the ECTHR in National Case Law-A comparative analysis, (Intersentia, Cambridge - Antwerp – Portland, 2014).Search in Google Scholar

Gerards, Janneke, “The European Court of Human Rights and the National Courts: Giving Shape to the Notion of ‘Shared Responsibility’,” in Gerards, Janneke and Fleuren, Joseph (eds.), Implementation of the European Convention on Human Rights and of the Judgments of the ECtHR in National Case Law: A Comparative Analysis (Intersentia, Cambridge – Antwerp – Portland, 2014).Search in Google Scholar

Greer, S., The Margin of Appreciation: Interpretation and Discretion under the European Convention on Human Rights (Council of Europe, 2000).Search in Google Scholar

Greer, S., The European Convention on Human Rights: Achievements, Problems and Prospects, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2006).10.1017/CBO9780511494963Search in Google Scholar

Hartwig, Matthias, The Institutionalization of the Rule of Law: The Establishment of Constitutional Courts in the Eastern European Countries, 7 American University International Law Review, no. 3 (1992).Search in Google Scholar

Hasani, Enver, Basic Features of the Constitutional System in Kosovo, 61 Rule of Law, no. 2 (2017).10.1007/978-3-319-55186-9_8Search in Google Scholar

Hasani, Enver, The Relationship Between the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Kosovo, Journal for Juridical and Social Issues, no. 2 (2016).Search in Google Scholar

Hasani, Enver, Constitutional Review (University of Pristina, 2021).Search in Google Scholar

Home official of the Council Court, available at: <https://www.gjyqesori-rks.org/aktgjykimet/?lang=en>, accessed November 26, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Istrefi, Kushtrim, Constitutional Acquisition of International Human Rights in the Legal Order of Kosovo, Journal of Law, no. 1 (2013).Search in Google Scholar

Janneke, Gerards, The Irrelevance of the Netherlands Constitution, and the Impossibility of Changing It, 77 Revue Interdisciplinaire d’Études Juridiques, no. 2 (2016).10.3917/riej.077.0207Search in Google Scholar

Jones and others v. United Kingdom , ECHR App. Nos. 34356/06 & 40528/06 [2014], available at: <https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/fre#{%22itemid%22:[%22001-140005%22]}>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Judgment of the Czech Constitutional Court of March 22, 2005, Pl. ÚS 45/08, available at: <https://www.usoud.cz/en/decisions/2009-04-02-ii-us-1945-08-right-of-a-child-to-be-heard>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Judgment of the Czech Constitutional Court of May 27 2010, Pl. ÚS 13/10, available at: <https://www.usoud.cz/en/decisions/2010-09-07-pl-us-12-10-judges-pay-2010>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic of Feb. 17 2010, Pst 1/2009-348.Search in Google Scholar

Kosovo 2021 Human Rights Report, Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2021, United States Department of State, available at: <https://www.state.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/313615_KOSOVO-2021-HUMAN-RIGHTS-REPORT.pdf>, accessed November 27, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Kosovo Declaration of Independence (2008), available at: <http://old.kuvendikosoves.org/common/docs/Dek_Pav_sh.pdf>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Kosovo Institute for Justice, Practice of the ECtHR Obligation on Paper (Analysis of the implementation of the ECHR and the practice of the ECtHR by the courts of Kosovo (Prishtina, 2020).Search in Google Scholar

Law No. 06/l – 054 for Courts (2018), available at: <https://md.rks-gov.net/desk/inc/media/F6BADB4F-6CD7-42F2-9E54-9D01B98A778E.pdf>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Mac-Gregor, Eduardo Ferrer, Conventionality Control: The New Doctrine of The Inter-American Court of Human Rights (Washington: Cambridge University Press, Vol. 109, 2016).10.1017/S2398772300001240Search in Google Scholar

Malcolm, Noel, Kosovo: A Short History (New York University Press: New York, 1998).Search in Google Scholar

Mansfield, Nicolas, The Creation of the Constitutional Court: Lessons from Kosovo (East-West Management Institute, 2012).Search in Google Scholar

Oddný, Arnardóttir, Mjöll, Res Interpretata, Erga Omnes Effect and the Role of the Margin of Appreciation in Giving Domestic Effect to the Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights, 28 The European Journal of International Law, no. 3 (2017).10.1093/ejil/chx045Search in Google Scholar

Polakiewicz, J., The Application of the European Convention on Human Rights in Domestic Law, 17 Human Rights Law Journal (1996).Search in Google Scholar

Portugal’s Constitution of 1976, with Amendments through 2005, available at: <https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Portugal_2005.pdf>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Protocol No. 16 to the Convention on the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, available at: <Protocol No. 16 to the Convention (coe.int)>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Repetto, Giorgio (ed.), “Introduction the ECHR and the European Constitutional Landscape: Reassessing Paradigms,” in Giorgia Repetto (ed.), the Constitutional Relevance of the ECHR in Domestic and European Law—An Italian Perspective (Intersentia, Cambridge - Antwerp – Portland, 2013).Search in Google Scholar

“Report of the Civil Society on Human Rights in Kosovo in 2020,” OHCHR, available at: <2020_kosovo_cso_annual_human_rights_report_AL.pdf (ohchr.org)>, accessed November 27, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Slaughter, A.-M, A Global Community of Courts, 44 Harvard International Law Journal, no. 1 (2003).Search in Google Scholar

Spirovski, Igor, The Competence of The Constitutional Court to Control the Conformity of Laws with International Treaties: New Trends in Constitutional Justice, European Commission for Democracy Through Law (Venice Commission) (Strasbourg, 2009).Search in Google Scholar

Starke, Joseph G., “Monism and Dualism in the Theory of International Law, in Normativity and Norms-critical perspectives on Kelsenian themes” in Paulson, Stanley L. and Litschewski, Pasulson Bonnies (Eds), Normativity and Norms: Critical Perspectives on Kelsenian Themes, (Clarendon Press-Oxford, 1989).Search in Google Scholar

The European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission), Report on The Implementation of International Human Rights Treaties in Domestic Law and The Role of Courts, available at: <https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-AD(2014)036-e>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

The European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission), Study on Individual Access to Constitutional Justice (Venice, 17–18 December 2010), available at: <https://www.venice.coe.int/WebForms/documents/default.aspx?pdffile=CDL-AD(2010)039rev-e>, accessed November 26, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Ulfstein, G., “The European Court of Human Rights and National Courts: A Constitutional Relationship,” in Arnardóttir, O.M. and Buyse, A., (eds.), Shifting Centres of Gravity in Human Rights Protection (Routledge, 2016).10.4324/9781315651125-4Search in Google Scholar

Ulfstein, Geir, Transnational Constitutional Aspects of the European Court of Human Rights, Global Constitutionalism (Cambridge University Press, 2021).10.1017/S2045381719000303Search in Google Scholar

Vehabović, Faris, “Impact of the Case Law of the European Court of Human Rights on Post-Conflict Society of Bosnia and Herzegovina,” in Julian, Motoc and Ineta, Ziemele (eds), The Impact of the ECHR on Democratic Change in Central and Eastern Europe Judicial Perspectives (Cambridge University Press, 2016).10.1017/CBO9781316471340.007Search in Google Scholar

Viljanen, Jukka, The Role of the European Court of Human Rights as a Developer of International Human Rights Law, 1 Cuadernos Constitucionales de la Cátedra Fadrique Furió Ceriol, no. 62–63 (2008).Search in Google Scholar

Wildhaber, Luzius, The European Convention on Human Rights and International Law, 56 The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, no. 2 (2007).10.1093/iclq/lei163Search in Google Scholar

Wolfgang, Zeidler, Federal Constitutional Court of the Federal Republic of Germany: Decisions on the Constitutionality of Legal Norms, 62 Notre Dame Law Review, no. 4 (1987).Search in Google Scholar

European Court of Human Rights, Adoption of Final Resolutions (Husák v the Czech Republic, Case No. 19970/04 [2008] ECtHR; Krejčíř v the Czech Republic, Case No. 39298/04 and 8723/05 [2009] ECtHR; Knebl v the Czech Republic, Case No. 20157/05 [2010] ECtHR), available at: <https://rm.coe.int/native/09000016804d5fd4>, accessed November 25, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

“States in Transition 2012-Kosovo,” Freedom House, June 6, 2012, available at: <http://www.freedomhouse.org/report/nations-transit/2012/kosovo>, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar

Law No. 03/L-073 on General Elections in the Republic of Kosovo [2008], available at: <https://gzk.rks-gov.net/ActDetail.aspx?ActID=2544&langid=2>, accessed September 7, 2022.Search in Google Scholar

Personal interview with Judge Rafet Haxha, 22 July 2022.Search in Google Scholar

Personal interview with Judge Ramiz Kuçi, 22 July 2022.Search in Google Scholar

Personal interview with Professor Fejzullah Hasani, 18 August 2022.Search in Google Scholar

Personal interview with Judge Kreshnik Kaçiu, 27 July 2022 and Judge Rafet Haxha, 22 July 2022.Search in Google Scholar

Personal interview with Judge Kujtim Krasniqi, 27 July 2022.Search in Google Scholar

Sabri Hamiti and other deputies against the Decision of the Assembly of the Republic of Kosovo, No. 04-V-04, Case No. KO 29/11, available <https://gjk-ks.org/en/decision/constitutional-review-of-the-decision-of-the-assembly-of-the-republic-of-kosovo-no-04-v-04-concerning-the-election-of-the-president-2/, accessed November 28, 2023.Search in Google Scholar