The European Central Bank and Banking Supervision: The Regulatory Limits of the Single Supervisory Mechanism
-
Kern Alexander
The article analyses the European Central Bank’s supervisory role for banking institutions in the Single Supervisory Mechanism. The article assesses the nature and scope of the ECB’s supervisory powers under the Single Supervisory Mechanism Regulation (SSM Regulation) and questions whether it has adequate institutional capacity and legal competence to carry out effective banking supervision. The international regulatory reforms adopted by the G20 and the Financial Stability Board following the global financial crisis of 2007–2009 have emphasised the importance of macro-prudential supervision that is, monitoring financial stability risks across the financial system, rather than just supervising individual institutions. This has led many countries to adopt macroprudential regulatory reforms that link-up macroprudential supervision and monetary policy with microprudential supervision of individual institutions. This three pillar approach to financial regulation – involving macro-prudential supervision, micro-prudential supervision and monetary policy – has become an important feature in regulatory reforms of many countries and represents a more holistic and complementary approach to financial regulation. The article argues that the ECB under the EU Treaty and SSM Regulation does not have adequate competence and institutional capacity to conduct macroprudential supervision and the Regulation’s separation of ECB monetary policy operations from banking supervision limits its effectiveness as a banking supervisor as well as its conduct of monetary policy. Moreover, the article suggests that the ECB’s strong form of independence as set forth in the EU Treaty (though appropriate for monetary policy) is not suitable for its role as a bank supervisor and therefore amendments to the Treaty may be necessary to enhance its accountability to Council, Parliament and Member States. The article concludes that further institutional and legal changes are necessary for the ECB to have the necessary institutional and legal capacity to be an effective bank supervisor.
References
Alexander, K. Eatwell, J. Persaud, A. and Reoch, R. (2007) ‘Financial Supervision and Crisis Management in the EU’, European Parliament, Brussels.Search in Google Scholar
Alexander, K (13 November 2012) Proposals for a European Banking Union must be redesigned to provide a more accountable and effective institutional framework. EUROPP Public Policy blog, The London School of Economics and Political Science.Search in Google Scholar
Alexander, K (24 September 2012) European Banking Union: Implementation Challenges. Written and oral evidence before the House of Lords Committee on Europe.Search in Google Scholar
Alexander, K (2012) ‘Bank Capital Management and Macro-prudential Regulation’, 24 Journal of Banking Law 5:331–342.10.15375/zbb-2012-0503Search in Google Scholar
Allemand, F (2015) The ECB, The SSM and Differentiated Integration: The Legal Triangle of Incompatibility?, ECB Legal Conference 2015, ‘From Monetary Union to Banking Union, on the way to Capital Markets Union, New Opportunities for European Integration’, 305–324 available at: <http://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/other/frommonetaryuniontobankingunion201512.en.pdf>, accessed 25 February 2016.Search in Google Scholar
Andenas M and Snell J (2002) Exploring the Outer Limits: Restrictions on the Free Movement of Goods and Services. In: Andenas M and Roth W-H (eds), Services and Free Movement in EU Law, Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Andenas M and Hadjiemmannuilt C (1997) European Banking Supervision, the Internal Market and European Monetary Union. In: Andenas M, Gormley L, Hadjiemmanuilt C, & Harden I (eds) European Economic and Monetary Union: The Institutional Framework. Kluwer Law International.Search in Google Scholar
Brunnermeier M, Crockett A, Goodhart C, Persaud A, and Shin H (2009) The Fundamental Principles of Financial Regulation. Geneva Reports on the World Economy 11. Geneva: International Centre for Banking and Monetary Studies. Search in Google Scholar
Chambers D, Davies G and Monti G (2011) European Union Law: Text and Materials. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Davies H (2006) Comments on Cross-Border Banking Regulatory Challenges. In: Caprio G, Evanoff DD and Kaufman GG (eds.) Cross-Border Banking – Regulatory Challenges, Singapore: World Scientific.10.1142/9789812773418_0005Search in Google Scholar
Dermine J (2003) European Banking: Past, Present and Future. In Gaspar V, Hartmann P and Skeijpen O (eds.) The Transformation of the European Financial System, Second European Central Bank Conference, Frankfurt: European Central Bank.10.2139/ssrn.357500Search in Google Scholar
Ferran, E (2014) European Banking Union and the EU Single Financial Market: More Differentiated Integration or Disintegration?. In: Cambridge Legal Studies Research Papers 29/ 2014. <http://www.law.cam.ac.uk/ssrn>, accessed 28 October 2014.10.2139/ssrn.2426580Search in Google Scholar
Gortsos, Christos (2015) The Single Supervisory Mchanism (SSM), Athens: Nomihki. Search in Google Scholar
Lastra, R (2015) Reflections on Banking Union, Lender of Last Resort and Supervisory Discretion, In: ECB Legal Conference 2015 (Frankfurt: European Central Bank). 10.4324/9781315695464-7Search in Google Scholar
Van Rompuy, H, President of the European Council (26 June 2012) Towards a Genuine Economic and Monetary Union, Report EUCO 120/12, 1–2, Brussels. <http://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/focuson/crisis/documents/131201_en_pdf> accessed 28 October 2014.Search in Google Scholar
© 2016 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
Articles in the same Issue
- The European Central Bank and Banking Supervision: The Regulatory Limits of the Single Supervisory Mechanism
- The Optimal Scope of Disclosure by Association Regime under MAR
- A Hat That Fits on Different Heads? The Proposed Regulation on Money Market Funds and the System of EU Investment Law
Articles in the same Issue
- The European Central Bank and Banking Supervision: The Regulatory Limits of the Single Supervisory Mechanism
- The Optimal Scope of Disclosure by Association Regime under MAR
- A Hat That Fits on Different Heads? The Proposed Regulation on Money Market Funds and the System of EU Investment Law
