Entity Realism Meets the Pessimistic Meta-Induction Argument. The World is not Enough
-
Jacob Busch
Abstract
In the following I briefly set out Devitt's (Realism and Truth, Princeton University press, 1997) definition of entity realism and compare it to Hackings (1983) definition. I then set out the pessimistic induction argument as suggested by Putnam (Meaning and the Moral Sciences, Routledge & K. Paul, 1978). I present an argument developed by Bertolet (Dialectica vol. 42: 59–71, 1988) to the effect that Devitt's abductive defence of realism fails. In the light of its failure, Devitt offers the ability of his definition of scientific realism to solve the pessimistic induction argument as a tactical advantage for his definition. I argue that Devitt's account is not adequately suited for defending realism when confronted with the pessimistic induction argument. I do this by setting out three problems for Devitt. In particular I argue that Devitt does not provide an adequate account of how to identify entities across theories across time. I argue that his proposed solution employing ‘partial reference’ of terms generates a new pessimistic induction, and that Devitt's position does not provide an adequate account of how to make sense of the progress of science.
© Philosophia Press 2006
Articles in the same Issue
- Spiritual Objectivity. A systematic expansion of the body-mind-problem
- Finding a Place for Moral Theory
- Too Many Dispositional Properties
- The Problem of the Criterion, Skepticism, and the Cartesian Circle
- Limit-situation. Antinomies and Transcendence in Karl Jaspers' Philosophy
- Access to the Abstract: Intuition as Mental Modelling
- Entity Realism Meets the Pessimistic Meta-Induction Argument. The World is not Enough
- The Pessimistic Meta-Induction. A Response to Jacob Busch
- Casullo on the Nature and Existence of A Priori Justification
- Steen Ebbesen and Carl Henrik Koch, The Danish History of Philosophy, 5 volumes, Gyldendal 2002-2004
- Ole Fogh Kirkeby, Eventum tantum - begivenhedens ethos, 592 pages, Forlaget Samfundslitteratur, Copenhagen, 2005
- Alois Pichler and Simo Säätelä (eds.): Wittgenstein: The Philosopher and his Works. Working Papers from the Wittgenstein Archives at the University of Bergen no 17, Bergen 2005. 420 pages. ISBN 82-91071-20-9
Articles in the same Issue
- Spiritual Objectivity. A systematic expansion of the body-mind-problem
- Finding a Place for Moral Theory
- Too Many Dispositional Properties
- The Problem of the Criterion, Skepticism, and the Cartesian Circle
- Limit-situation. Antinomies and Transcendence in Karl Jaspers' Philosophy
- Access to the Abstract: Intuition as Mental Modelling
- Entity Realism Meets the Pessimistic Meta-Induction Argument. The World is not Enough
- The Pessimistic Meta-Induction. A Response to Jacob Busch
- Casullo on the Nature and Existence of A Priori Justification
- Steen Ebbesen and Carl Henrik Koch, The Danish History of Philosophy, 5 volumes, Gyldendal 2002-2004
- Ole Fogh Kirkeby, Eventum tantum - begivenhedens ethos, 592 pages, Forlaget Samfundslitteratur, Copenhagen, 2005
- Alois Pichler and Simo Säätelä (eds.): Wittgenstein: The Philosopher and his Works. Working Papers from the Wittgenstein Archives at the University of Bergen no 17, Bergen 2005. 420 pages. ISBN 82-91071-20-9
