Home 2 The Concepts of Populism
Chapter
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

2 The Concepts of Populism

View more publications by Lynne Rienner Publishers
REFERENCES TO POPULISM ABOUND IN BOTH THE MEDIA AND THE ACA-demicliterature. In newspapers and magazines one reads of populist move-ments, leaders, parties, policies, and regimes and of left-wing, right-wing,anti-immigrant, and economic populism. Newspapers describe the populistleanings of politicians and candidates in the United States, France, Russia,Argentina, and Bolivia, and their antineoliberal, antielite, anti-US, pro-nation, procitizen, pro-people rhetoric. Reports highlight populism’s fascistand socialist tendencies, along with its inherent authoritarianism and dem-ocratic inclusiveness. Given the variety of meanings associated with theconcept, little wonder that widely disparate politicians such as MahmoudAhmadinejad of Iran, Alberto Fujimori of Peru, and Marine Le Pen ofFrance have all carried the populist label. Further, that George W. Bush,Barack Obama, and Donald Trump have been described as populists con-firms the flexibility of the term (e.g., Frank 2004; Zakaria 2016; Zuboff2008).1Consideration of only the academic literature offers little respite fromthe confusion. Some authors emphasize the discursive nature of populismby focusing on identities centered on an us-versus-them division of society(e.g., Laclau 1977; Panizza 2005). Others locate populism in specific his-torical junctures or circumstances (e.g, Malloy 1977; Vilas 1992–1993),leading a few to conclude that it is a thing of the past (e.g., Schamis 2006).Another group describes populism purely in economic terms, as a set ofpolicy outcomes (e.g., Dornbusch and Edwards 1991; Edwards 2010; Sachs1990). Yet another argues for a purely political understanding of the term(e.g., Leaman 2004; Weyland 2001).These circumstances have led some analysts to call for the abandon-ment of the concept altogether (e.g., Roxborough 1984). However, the fre-quency of the term’s usage in the literature and the periodic reemergence of232TheConceptsofPopulism
© 2022, Lynne Rienner Publishers, Boulder, USA

REFERENCES TO POPULISM ABOUND IN BOTH THE MEDIA AND THE ACA-demicliterature. In newspapers and magazines one reads of populist move-ments, leaders, parties, policies, and regimes and of left-wing, right-wing,anti-immigrant, and economic populism. Newspapers describe the populistleanings of politicians and candidates in the United States, France, Russia,Argentina, and Bolivia, and their antineoliberal, antielite, anti-US, pro-nation, procitizen, pro-people rhetoric. Reports highlight populism’s fascistand socialist tendencies, along with its inherent authoritarianism and dem-ocratic inclusiveness. Given the variety of meanings associated with theconcept, little wonder that widely disparate politicians such as MahmoudAhmadinejad of Iran, Alberto Fujimori of Peru, and Marine Le Pen ofFrance have all carried the populist label. Further, that George W. Bush,Barack Obama, and Donald Trump have been described as populists con-firms the flexibility of the term (e.g., Frank 2004; Zakaria 2016; Zuboff2008).1Consideration of only the academic literature offers little respite fromthe confusion. Some authors emphasize the discursive nature of populismby focusing on identities centered on an us-versus-them division of society(e.g., Laclau 1977; Panizza 2005). Others locate populism in specific his-torical junctures or circumstances (e.g, Malloy 1977; Vilas 1992–1993),leading a few to conclude that it is a thing of the past (e.g., Schamis 2006).Another group describes populism purely in economic terms, as a set ofpolicy outcomes (e.g., Dornbusch and Edwards 1991; Edwards 2010; Sachs1990). Yet another argues for a purely political understanding of the term(e.g., Leaman 2004; Weyland 2001).These circumstances have led some analysts to call for the abandon-ment of the concept altogether (e.g., Roxborough 1984). However, the fre-quency of the term’s usage in the literature and the periodic reemergence of232TheConceptsofPopulism
© 2022, Lynne Rienner Publishers, Boulder, USA
Downloaded on 21.9.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9781626376694-004/html?licenseType=restricted&srsltid=AfmBOooZzR6jMLgj41g-sPZFAqgY8dLiFl3PTPrwH1QByLle1i0j9VR4
Scroll to top button