Home Linguistics & Semiotics Zur Kommasetzung im Deutschen
Chapter
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

Zur Kommasetzung im Deutschen

  • Martin Neef
Become an author with De Gruyter Brill
Explore this Subject How to publish with us
Vergleichende Interpunktion – Comparative Punctuation
This chapter is in the book Vergleichende Interpunktion – Comparative Punctuation

Abstract

This paper reconstructs the current comma placement in Germanwithin the framework of theModular Theory ofWriting Systems (cf. Neef 2005; 2015). For this purpose, three conditions are formulated, which - in the sense of a syntactic principle - provide certain markers for the syntactic constructions co-subordination, sentence, and infinitive phrase. The conditions are conceived as both inviolable and unordered and they apply to German in a language-specific way. The special feature of the conditions is that they are not conceived as comma rules, prescribing the placement of commas in certain positions. Rather, within the syntactic constructions certain positions are identified that require marking. The comma is only one of the marking options; it is the default, which is used if no other marking is present. In this way, all comma positions that are obligatory according to the currently valid norm are captured, and to a small extent also facultative ones. In favor of the simplicity of the explanation, other optional comma positions are considered a systematic complication and are ignored in the model.

Abstract

This paper reconstructs the current comma placement in Germanwithin the framework of theModular Theory ofWriting Systems (cf. Neef 2005; 2015). For this purpose, three conditions are formulated, which - in the sense of a syntactic principle - provide certain markers for the syntactic constructions co-subordination, sentence, and infinitive phrase. The conditions are conceived as both inviolable and unordered and they apply to German in a language-specific way. The special feature of the conditions is that they are not conceived as comma rules, prescribing the placement of commas in certain positions. Rather, within the syntactic constructions certain positions are identified that require marking. The comma is only one of the marking options; it is the default, which is used if no other marking is present. In this way, all comma positions that are obligatory according to the currently valid norm are captured, and to a small extent also facultative ones. In favor of the simplicity of the explanation, other optional comma positions are considered a systematic complication and are ignored in the model.

Chapters in this book

  1. Frontmatter I
  2. Vorwort V
  3. Preface VII
  4. Inhaltsverzeichnis/Contents IX
  5. Einleitung XIII
  6. Introduction XXIII
  7. System
  8. Zur Kommasetzung im Deutschen 3
  9. ‹/›, ‹,› und ‹,› – Variation und Wandel in der Entwicklung der Kommas im 17. und 18. Jh. aus graph(emat)ischer Perspektive 25
  10. Das Komma in kontrastiver Perspektive Italienisch–Deutsch 57
  11. Punctuation Principles in the Glagolitic and Cyrillic Printed Works of the Croatian Protestant Printing Press in Urach (1561–1564) 73
  12. Norm
  13. Isolating the Syntactic Factor in Non-Standard Punctuation 91
  14. Vom genormten Satzbau zur genormten Interpunktion 109
  15. Gebrauch/Use
  16. Textsegmentierung in Handschrift und Frühdruck 137
  17. Interpunktion in historischen Patientenbriefen 163
  18. Japanische Interpunktion im Wandel der Zeit 187
  19. An Investigation of the Factors Influencing Chinese Readers’ Perception of Sentence Boundaries in Mandarin 215
  20. The Colon in English, German and Swedish: A Contrastive Corpus-Based Study 237
  21. Comparing Word Marks 263
  22. The Ellipsis and the Dash in Italian and English: A Contrastive Perspective 289
  23. Erwerb/Acquisition
  24. Interpunktion – (K)ein Thema für Deutsch als Fremdsprache? 317
  25. Deutsch und Dänisch im Vergleich: Die Verwendung des Ausrufezeichens 343
  26. Zur Kommasetzung italienischer DaF-Lernender 369
  27. Sachregister/Index 397
  28. Interpunktionszeichenregister/Index of Punctuation Marks 407
  29. Adressen/Addresses 413
https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110756319-001

Chapters in this book

  1. Frontmatter I
  2. Vorwort V
  3. Preface VII
  4. Inhaltsverzeichnis/Contents IX
  5. Einleitung XIII
  6. Introduction XXIII
  7. System
  8. Zur Kommasetzung im Deutschen 3
  9. ‹/›, ‹,› und ‹,› – Variation und Wandel in der Entwicklung der Kommas im 17. und 18. Jh. aus graph(emat)ischer Perspektive 25
  10. Das Komma in kontrastiver Perspektive Italienisch–Deutsch 57
  11. Punctuation Principles in the Glagolitic and Cyrillic Printed Works of the Croatian Protestant Printing Press in Urach (1561–1564) 73
  12. Norm
  13. Isolating the Syntactic Factor in Non-Standard Punctuation 91
  14. Vom genormten Satzbau zur genormten Interpunktion 109
  15. Gebrauch/Use
  16. Textsegmentierung in Handschrift und Frühdruck 137
  17. Interpunktion in historischen Patientenbriefen 163
  18. Japanische Interpunktion im Wandel der Zeit 187
  19. An Investigation of the Factors Influencing Chinese Readers’ Perception of Sentence Boundaries in Mandarin 215
  20. The Colon in English, German and Swedish: A Contrastive Corpus-Based Study 237
  21. Comparing Word Marks 263
  22. The Ellipsis and the Dash in Italian and English: A Contrastive Perspective 289
  23. Erwerb/Acquisition
  24. Interpunktion – (K)ein Thema für Deutsch als Fremdsprache? 317
  25. Deutsch und Dänisch im Vergleich: Die Verwendung des Ausrufezeichens 343
  26. Zur Kommasetzung italienischer DaF-Lernender 369
  27. Sachregister/Index 397
  28. Interpunktionszeichenregister/Index of Punctuation Marks 407
  29. Adressen/Addresses 413
Sign up now to receive a 20% welcome discount
Institutional Access
How does access work?
Have an idea on how to improve our website?
Please write us.
© 2025 De Gruyter Brill
Downloaded on 2.11.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110756319-001/html
Scroll to top button